Doom and gloom is nothing new for Star Trek. The franchises has ended what feels like a billion times before Youtube told us Kurtzman was fired every few months. But even with a lead character dead and their body shot into space, Trek finds a way.
Revived for the big screen ten years after being cancelled, Star Trek found a new lease of life following a surge in popularity through the 70’s. With the success of 1979’s Motion Picture came a complete retool of everything with the hugely popular Wrath of Khan three years later; a film that saw an older Admiral Kirk take command of his old ship to face one of his greatest enemies. AN enemy he could only defeat thanks to his former first officer Spock giving his life to save the crew.
The Wrath of Khan was the end of the road, or so many thought. So killing off Spock was a way to close that chapter of their lives and move on to other projects. But of course, the second outing was also a success, but director Nick Meyer had a feeling it would be and put in a caveat. Before his death, Spock mind melded with Dr McCoy and told him to remember…
Limping back home following the defeat of Khan Noonien Singh, the death of Spock is weighing heavy on Admiral Kirk’s mind. Everyone’s going home to be reassigned and the old and battered Enterprise is being put to pasture. Scotty’s got anew job lined up on the fancy new Excelsior, McCoy’s dealing with some emotional distress thanks to Spock and Kirk settled back into his desk job life only to end up on a personal mission thanks to Spock’s old man, Sarek.
Spocks body may have died, but his ‘soul’ was still alive. Vulcans of great importance aren’t supposed to have their bodies shot into space. They’ve brought home, their consciousness and memories removed and stuffed into a big archive. Spock knew he was dying, so he transferred his consciousness to McCoy before melting inside a reactor room. With Kirk now well aware he made a whoopsie, and why Bones has goner weird on him, the plans set: Get McCoy, get a ship, and then go retrieve Spock’s body to put everything back together and warp off to Vulcan before Sarek throws a show at him.
It’s one of the tightest openings of the series. Everything’s laid out quickly. The film starts with a replay of Spocks death and doesn’t waste time. Sure, it doesn’t feel swift with everyone in mourning. But it’s all laid out quick and simple as it needs to be.
When it comes to Star Trek films, it’s generally accepted that the odd numbered ones are the worst. The Search for Spock kind of started that reputation, though it’s a little unfair. Even at this stage, Star Trek carried some baggage. The first film tried to reinvent the 60’s camp style for a more cold and serious sci fi style. It was a hit, but so vastly odd in comparison to what people liked, it narratively and thematically not drowned out by the more intimate and charismatic sequel which, in itself, carried baggage of dragging a baddie of the week into the main plot.
Khan succeeded as it was easy to give the background in a few lines. We just had to know Khan hates Kirk and wants revenge. For TSFS things get a little more complicated. First off, Spocks deader than a can of spam so even with his name in the title, you’ve lost one of the main aspects of what made Star Trek famous. Secondly,it’s such a direct continuation of the story that it comes with a lot of baggage.
To it’s credit, the film does try and keep things self contained by replaying Spocks death over again before the credits and doesn’t waste time in explaining why following Sarek’s wishes is a problem despite focusing on mourning. Not just of Spock, but of the end of an era for them all while giving a peek behind the curtain of Federation politics; something that never got this close to home before in the series. It does feel a little bit clunky as the whole first act isn’t just following up from the end of the second, but giving a chunk more set up.
Basically: Kirk needs to get Spocks body and re-merge it with McCoy. But the Genesis Planet is the heart of a political poop storm. Kirk’s been barred from going so being the mature Admiral he’s become, he steals the Enterprise with his old crew and does what he wants anyway. Meanwhile that poop storm has attracted some rogue Klingons who also decide to go to Genesis believing it could be turned into a weapon; meanwhile Saavik and David Marcus find Spocks coffin. But Spocks body isn’t inside…
The joys of story telling means that some weird stuff happen in the first part of the film. Kirk stealing the Enterprise is a very Kirk idea, especially if you go in with a bit of history to these characters. Though knocking out the Excelsior and getting away does add to the “only ship in range” trope as it seems no other ship is in range to chase the Enterprise. Also Uhura getting their exit plan together just to sit out the rest of the film is a bit of a weird choice.
But it all works with the whole escape from Spacedock being quick and fun. In contrast, Saavika nd David on Genesis slows things down but in a more interesting way than it should be. Their part is slow, oohing and awwing at the weird DIY planet before finding Spocks body reborn, rapidly ageing from child to adult scene by scene. The Klingons joining in, stranding the scientists and creating a hostage situation also gives it a bit of tension.
It’s when it all combined that the Klingon part kicks off though. Christopher Lloyd is a fun antagonist as Kruge. It also brings a real threat: putting Kirk on the back heel with the Enterprise barely functional, the Klingons ready to strike and hostages on the ground. Though it’s when Kruge’s men kill David in a struggle that the tension rises. Crushed by the loss of a son he’s only just started to know, and facing defeat, Kirk hands over the Enterprise. With a caveat. As he beams over the Klingons, beams his own crew to Genesis and leaves his enemy to face the ships self destruct.
The death of the Enterprise is one of the most memorable moments form the film. Sure, the end of a Starship may not be as shocking now, but seeing the iconic Enterprise come to an end was a fairly big deal. Though as memorable as that moment was, it often overshadows Shatner playing Kirk’s reaction to Davids death; one of his best moments in the film era of his tenure.
If the film ended there, it would likely rank a lot higher. Unfortunately the tension bubble is well and truly burst when Kirk and Kruge meet. Whether it’s the obviously dodgy sets or the ridiculously horrible fight sequence – which includes a comically fake leg – once the Enterprise is gone things just drag out. There’s no real excitement in the confrontation,, on taking the Klingons ship or even in getting the revived – and by this point conveniently aged – Spock back to Vulcan to restore his consciousness and essentially cheat death with little fanfare.
In some ways it felt like there was something missing by the end. It’s a bit of a mixed bag of a film. There’s a lot to enjoy, in reality and some really good sequences. From the tension before the Enterprise blows to Sarek’s plea to Kirk. Even the conversation between Kirk and the Fleet Admiral – “The answer is no.” – makes for good viewing. Combined through it does feel like something missing. Maybe it was the clearly cut budget. Maybe it just needed a revised ending so it felt like the build and tension paid off.
Overall, it’s not a bad film. But as it stands, it’s just not a great film either. But luck would be on their side in hindsight. As it turns out, killing Spock wasn’t the end. And neither was killing the Enterprise. A fourth last chance would come making TSFS the middle movie in an accidental trilogy. As a one of movie it was good but forgettable.
Becoming the cool down episode sandwiched between two of Star Trek’s most popular films? It fares better than other films in the odd numbered curse and at the very least, delivered some brilliant moments that rank high for the original line up.
About the author
Comms/Comms Relay Revisions from Beta Quarter 2025 Onwards
Following our last released issue of Comms as a downloadable publication, we've been moving to an easier and more accessible format by using Q2's website for various articles and updates throughout the year which has included some carry over features from Comms itself. After some trial and error experimentation, our 2025 plan began with some tests through the first quarter and a new comms line up for the site ahead of any plans by our next Fleet Comms Officer. To mirror the old style, reduce workload and offer some variety to our regular posts, we've broken down the year of updates through our operating quarters and scheduled in a rotation of our regular features to keep the fleet updated, entertained with some positive Trek hijinks and more. The current quarter (Beta Quarter: April, May, June) is the first full use […]
[Q2&A] If I Could Get Serial For A Minute…
With a long history and many people coming to SFC over the decades, there can often be a lot of curiosity for members – both old and new – about various subjects. From questions about our base structure, how to get four pips, how Q2 and Q1 diverged many moons ago.... even questions on the curse of the Daring. Sometimes we have questions where the answers are as mundane as the question. One of the most common.... what is my serial number and why do I have it? Like any account number in the known universe – whether it's your broadband provider or local Blockbusters – your service ID is a unique membership number that helps us identify each member whether we're updating a record or assessing a Fleet Support application form. With our structure and organisational systems based on […]
[Retro Review] Latent Image; Voyager S5E11
Running through annual check-ups and playing around with a 24th century version of a digital camera, the Doctor spots some weird scars on Ensign Kim. Scars that could only have come from a surgical procedure he developed, but has no memory of ever performing. The surgery isn't the only gap in the Doctors memory. What else has he forgotten? And how...? No matter the show or the season, Star Trek loves diving into the lives of it's artificial characters. Data explored everything from his basic rights to the meaning of dreams as he developed to become more of a person. For the Doctor, things had always been a bit more complicated. He was a program developed for short term use. A piece of equipment built into sickbay that could be turned off and on at will. While Deep Space Nine's […]
A New Class: Academy Revisions For The Class of 2402
It's only April and the year has been one for us to take a step back and review our operations to do some much overdue maintenance on our overall performance and offerings. One of the major hurdles for the second quarter is one of the tougher parts of Q2: The Academy. Once upon a time the Academy was a core part of the experience in joining SFC. After singing up new members would pass through the Academy, completing a series of tests before becoming an ensign, joining their unit and becoming an active member of the club. Many people over the years enjoyed the more immersive and playful nature of being part of an organisation modelled after Starfleet. Some didn't. As years went by, the franchise itself evolved, opening it's door to new fans who'd want to reach out and […]
A Fistful of Vulcan Emotions
Being a key element in the Sstar Trek lore from the very beginning, Vulcan mythology can often seem distorted by simplicity. Seen as a stoney emotionless species, their society is built on logic and science in helping them understand and navigate through the complexities of the universe. Though when it comes to them being emotionless, nothing could be farther from the truth. Once a volatile and primitive species, the Vulcan culture came from the teaching of Surak who learned to repress his violent urges and find peace within logical thought. Surak's teachings would become the basis for Vulcan core values for centuries. When it came to the original series, Vulcans were introduced through Spock – a half Vulcan with a human mother who often wrestled with the cultural norm of repressing emotions alongside the human half's more emotional state. Over […]
[Retro Review] Year Of Hell: Voyager Season 4
Embracing all aspects of science fiction has been Star Trek's thing since it's inception and time travel was no exception. Ever since the first time travel adventure with Kirk's Enterprise ending up in the 1960's, we've seen the various crews out of time and desperately trying not to change their own history. In one adventure, history would constantly change around the USS Voyager. One of the most memorable and loved two parters, Year of Hell remains a symbol of how desperate the situation could have been for the Voyager crew. As Janeway negotiations with an alien species for free travel through their region, a small annoyance of a ship interrupts them. Then suddenly, the timeline changed. The aliens, the Zahl, were gone. Erased from history. And the unsophisticated Krenim ship that was no match for Voyager one second was now […]
Related
[Retro Review] Latent Image; Voyager S5E11
Running through annual check-ups and playing around with a 24th century version of a digital camera, the Doctor spots some weird scars on Ensign Kim. Scars that could only have come from a surgical procedure he developed, but has no memory of ever performing. The surgery isn't the only gap in the Doctors memory. What else has he forgotten? And how...? No matter the show or the season, Star Trek loves diving into the lives of it's artificial characters. Data explored everything from his basic rights to the meaning of dreams as he developed to become more of a person. For the Doctor, things had always been a bit more complicated. He was a program developed for short term use. A piece of equipment built into sickbay that could be turned off and on at will. While Deep Space Nine's […]
[Retro Review] Year Of Hell: Voyager Season 4
Embracing all aspects of science fiction has been Star Trek's thing since it's inception and time travel was no exception. Ever since the first time travel adventure with Kirk's Enterprise ending up in the 1960's, we've seen the various crews out of time and desperately trying not to change their own history. In one adventure, history would constantly change around the USS Voyager. One of the most memorable and loved two parters, Year of Hell remains a symbol of how desperate the situation could have been for the Voyager crew. As Janeway negotiations with an alien species for free travel through their region, a small annoyance of a ship interrupts them. Then suddenly, the timeline changed. The aliens, the Zahl, were gone. Erased from history. And the unsophisticated Krenim ship that was no match for Voyager one second was now […]
[Retro Review] Lost In Space: The Caretaker. Voyager S1E1.
These days we're a bit spoiled as Star Trek fans. In less than ten years we've had three live action series, two animated shows and there's more on the way. And we have the internet so naturally we'll see everyone complain about it before there's even a trailer. In the mid-90's, things were a little more exciting. The hurdle of Next Gen replacing the original – now fully retired - crew was out the way. DS9 had taken a risk away from the Enterprise and now it was time for a new ship to carry the idea of boldly going forward. In comparison to the giant Enterprise flying the flag of the Federation, Voyager was a more average low key type of deal with a a bit of a makeshift crew that would have everything from a rookie to a […]
No One Expects The Starfleet Inquisition! Retro Review: Inquisition, DS9 S6E18
Stopped from heading to a quiet medical conference, Doctor Bashir is locked down with the crew of Deep Space Nine when internal investigations officer Sloan arrives. Apparently Deep Space Nine has a security breach. Information's being leaked to the enemy and all leads point to one person: Julian Bashir. It's a nice rarity when this era of Star Trek plays out it's story of the week without a B-Plot and Inquisition does it all quiet nicely. Especially as everything's played out from the perspective of Bashir as he's separated from his colleagues which enhances the tense paranoia of whats happening as Sloan probes through evidence that points to the doctor betraying the Federation. Thematically it's a story told many times before, even previously told in Star Trek, but with DS9's tone becoming a little darker by this stage, it worked […]
[Retro Review] Generations (1994)
Kirk's era my have started the phenomenon, but 1994 was a different era. Picard's Enterprise crew had just finished more than twice the amount of seasons of the original with one spin off finding it's feet and another in the pipeline. With the original crew having said their goodbyes in the Undiscovered country, the old was already out and the not quite as old were ready to take over the film branch of the Star Trek franchise. But not without a weird handover ceremony. Years after his final voyage as captain, Kirk is dragged out of retirement to sit in a chair and smile politely as a new captain launched with a new Enterprise. Of course, the new captain was typically useless so when the Enterprise was the only ship in range again, and the ship was dragged into an […]
[Retro Review] Schisms; TNG Season 6
Alien abduction isn't exactly an innovative or creative plot device. Long before the X Files became the most popular brand of alien conspiracy in media, we had everything from the memorably dazzling abduction in Close Encounters of the Third Kind to the found footage wonder The McPherson Tape. For Star Trek, however, it's an odd concept to include. Humanity is a space faring species and some of our best pals are aliens. If one crept into your bedroom in the middle of the night and took you on board their ship, that's more of a diplomatic nightmare than a horrific conspiracy. So when it did happen in Next Gen's Schisms it all felt a bit weird and creepy. Mostly in a good way.
