Background

[Retro Review] Best of Both Worlds

Article arrow_drop_down

The word ‘Legacy’ has been storming every corner of fan circles since the closing episode of Star Trek Picard which saw the former captains story with the Borg come full circle in more ways than one. While showrunner Terry Matalas has said there’s nothing confirmed with Paramount to his grand plan to continue the stage set by the finale, we’re digging into the Comms archive to look back at one of the touch stones of the seasons story arcs.

In one of the most dramatic moments of the show, Picard had to face an ugly truth when Titan’s Captain Liam Shaw reminded Picard where they’d met before: Wold 359. Shaw, an unseasoned junior officer at the time surviving by luck of the draw while Locutus, a shell of Picard himself, waged war against Earth and the Federation.

The following article first appeared in out Alan Van Spring Issue of Comms, released in May 2019. The issue is available to download in full PDF format for all SFCQ2 members.

Once upon a time Q zapped the Enterprise into the Delta Quadrant and shoved them in front of a cybernetic force of evil called the Borg. For… reasons. Who really knows why Q does anything. They were zapped back home after their excursion through fear, where Picard wrote a memo to Starfleet Command. Which I imagine said “there’s freaky robot people out there and I think I told them where we live. Soz. Tea anyone?”

After coming home, Picard and his crew went on their merry way dancing between the mad politics of the Klingons, sneaking about with Romulans and drinking enough Earl Grey to raise the question of where the bridge toilet is. Meanwhile Starfleet Command were in a bit of a tizzy and up hearing of the cybernetic murderbots, they began to prepare for them.

A season and a half after hearing nothing from the mysterious Borg, the Enterprise responds to a distress call at Jouret IV. By the time they arrive they find the whole colony had been ‘scooped’ off the face of the planet. Something that was becoming disturbingly common lately. Starfleet blames the Borg.

To confirm this Admiral Hanson brings his new Borg expert Commander Shelby. Who he confirms is the new Riker. Which is an interesting, if a little obvious, subplot and one of the ost aggressive signs of grumpy Riker.

Despite the seriousness of the mission, Hanson is also piggy backing his intentions to get Riker his own ship. It’s one of the eternal frustrations of the show; Riker is the next big thing, destined for command, but for some reason he always turns it down. Maybe because the Enterprise has comfy chairs and the other ships in the fleet have redressed bridges from the 23rd century and only appear as stock footage. Who knows.

Aside from being our resident Borg expert, Shelby is also the new Riker. He doesn’t like that idea. After all, the ideas ridiculous. She doesn’t have a beard. So he sulks, moans to Troi a bit, has to hear Picard tell him to grow up and stop wasting his time and of course, argues with the new girl. All the while NewRiker is down in engineering doing her job.

It’s an odd subplot, but keep that in mind for later.

The core of this episode though is that the Borg have arrived, and Shelby managed to find the cube thats been causing hassle and wrecking colonies. Hot footing it to the cube they try their new anti-Borg phasers. Anti Borg tactics, which work. For a time. But the Borg are one step ahead, continue their chase, board the ship and steal the Captain.

As Riker takes command, Shelby leads a team to the Borg cube to steal him right back. But they’re too late. Outnumbered by the unstoppable Borg who have the ability to adapt to all weapons, they discover Picard has already been implanted with Borg tech and is now one of them.

The first half of the Best of Both Worlds had it’s flaws. The emergence of sudden Grumpy Riker being one of them as they continue to offer no reason as to why he’d turn down his command so many times. The Enterprise isn’t that nice! It also gives us no reason to empathise with him as, to be honest, he’s just acting like a moody teenager who needs Bishop Brennan’d. It’s one of the worst traits of Riker that would pop up again over the years as it removes the likeability and charm he was introduced with and replaces it with him just being a bit of an arse.

Shelby is also a bit unlikeable as she’s too eager to advance and just becomes annoying in places. Also her big plan to split the ship in two pieces so the Borg would have to contest with two targets is a little bit frustrating as the saucer section really should have been used as a lifeboat to get the families and civilians out of harms way. No one ever thinks of the children.

Despite some glaring issues, the first part was a nice reintroduction to the Borg, and one that set some new ground rules from the vague hints we had back in Q Who. For one, there was no sight of a Borgified baby which at the time suggested they would breed and cyber-themselves up; something which wasn’t really addressed again until we saw assimilated children in Voyager. Of course the Borg would be redefined a few times, particularly with First Contact and the Voyager era and some parts introduced in Best of Both Worlds wouldn’t return. Such as the disappearing colonies.

The key though was ensuring that we know Starfleet have the fear, don’t quite know how to handle the situation and of course, the tension of them taking Picard – a revered Captain – into their collective which in itself led to the last scene of Part One; Riker in command, facing down a Borg Cube and the hive calling for a bit of a chinwag with their new Avatar: Locutus.

The final scene left us on Star Trek’s first big cliffhanger. Borg-Picard on one side, Riker on the other and the bearded grumpy one only giving one order: Fire.

For the sidetracking with some really odd character work that just didn’t seem to go anywhere worthwhile in that hour, the underlying tension followed by the last ten minutes made up for it. Jean Luc Picard was now the enemy; an enemy that Riker had no choice but to fire upon. Fade to black, see ya next year!

Another notable thing was how that happened, which was quite a visual treat as we watched Picard be informed, then transformed as his skin was bleached out, hs body chopped up and mechanical doodads installed all over; including replacing his arm with a big chunky claw. Which was actually quite horrifying in the beige filled Next Generation era.

After a long, long wait the show came back and changes were made. The stand off against Picard fizzled out, but the threat was still there. And so was Admiral Hanson who bumped Rikr up to Captain, giving some finality to his unwillingness to leave the Enterprise, but his desire to still be captain. And Shelby became first officer, just as she wanted. Everybody wins! Well, apart from Picard who was a Borg now. And Starfleet who still had to face the fact that one of their most knowledgeable tacticians was now informing the enemies hive mind and they still had no way to stop them at all.

Despite my grumbling over “Comfortable Grumpy Riker” there is the feeling that everyone’s pressuring him towards an exit. But by the end of the first episode, it’s Picard who’s out of the picture, so Riker getting his promotion after questioning himself and his future is a nice touch. After counselling Picard in the first half, Guinan shows up in the second to again give her words of wisdom, which lets us know this is a proper handover. Riker’s the skipper now and she reminds him of that; and that he needs to let go of Picard and take hold of his command.

When the second part opens and he starts to take command – and in turn suddenly learns how to not treat Shelby like a Pakled handyman – we learn that Picard’s knowledge of his former crew and of Starfleet in general had him prepare in advance. So radical thinkings in order.

Of course radical thinking doesn’t happen on an Admiralty level, and instead Hanson just throws as many ships as he can gather at Picards cube, which is determined to assimilate the entire population of Earth. Did anyone think that would work? Apparently so as there’s shock and surprise that we only see the aftermath of the battle and the forty ships that were just as ineffective against the Borg as the Enterprise was.

In a classic race against time, and because this time there might actually be a logical reason why the Enterprise is the only ship in the quadrant, it’s up to Captain Beardly, and there’s no time to grump his way through this one. Revisiting a plan they formed with Picard – to separate the saucer as a distraction (which is seriously still an issue unless they moved the civilians off ship) – Riker does the old bait and switch. Lotucus/Picard obviously ignores it, but wait! Data and Worf are on board the saucer and since it’s being ignored, the Borg don’t see them beaming over and finally stealing their Captain back! That advice Guinan gave Riker got ignored real fast!

Now with Picard in their possession, we get to see Data android it up and plug himself into the Artist Formerly Known As Picard, helping the Captain to fight against his assimilation. Picard resists, helps Data hack into the Borg Cube and give them the order to ‘sleep’; with the threat neutralised, Riker lets the cube explode to ensure it’s eliminated as Picard is taken down to sickbay to be downgraded back to an average human.

The second half isn’t as good as the first. It does pay off several threads from the first half, such as Riker’s loss of direction, which becomes restored with his Captaincy; Picards capture, which is explored further as he still fights against his assimilation and with the little details such as Shelby’s decoy plan paying off in the end (with a few tweaks). We also see more of the Borg’s capabilities through the wreckage of the fleet and the panic Starfleet has over them.

It also has some really dodgy dialogue and unintentionally silly moments. In contrast to that, Worf and Data’s rescue mission in the middle of a firefight was an exciting little mission that was very nicely put together, ad the Data-Picard mind link gave for some nice moments, despite their easy solution to silencing the Borg.

But it was disappointing that a lot of the character work didn’t really matter. When alls said and done, the Borg are gone because they mysteriously exploded and Picards make-under see’s him back in his ready room with a cup of tea. In the background the devastation was there, the fleet needed captains to make up for their losses and we’re left with the reminder that Riker’s career prospects as a heroic Captain who saved Earth are now incredible. Yet by the next episode, he’s back by Picards side and Shelby gets a new job off screen.

As a single story though, it works incredibly well. The first half sets up incredible tension with each moment slowly building to it’s climax. The second, while getting off to a understandable anticlimactic start, turns the desperation to defeat the Borg into an opportunity to save the captain while still keeping that tension level high.

As a reintroduction to the Borg it’s a brilliant two parter. Some elements of the Borg legacy were adapted and extended later on, but here the building blocks of what was to come were laid very nicely and would become a key part of the Next Generation era for years to come…

About the author

About the author

ADM JT Marczynka, DoFA

Creator of things, writer of words, caffeine addict. Director of Communications for Starfleet Command Quadrant 2.

More posts Follow

trending_flat
Fleet Support Recruitment: Alpha Quarter 2025

Following SFC's 50th anniversary, and looking ahead to whats to come in 2025 and beyond, we've been working on bolstering our fleet-wide operational support and opening the floor for officers to take a larger role in our operations. As part of our redefining our Fleet Support department, five roles were opened up to give more room for members to contribute beyond their unit and help shape the next generation of the club. Our first recruitment event saw two members brought on board to the Fleet Support panel and as we race through our first quarter of the year, we have the final three roles ready for recruitment! FLEET SUPPORT SFCQ2's Fleet Support division has been designed to aid and supplement membership opportunities and solidify a helpful, informative and supportive structure. Each role acts as a secondment to allow members to […]

trending_flat
For The Uniform: The Muted Tones of The Motion Picture

Starfleet's wardrobe always seems to change. Different producers and designers always bring something new to the table, whether it's a need to create a more militarised uniform, something nice and simple for a more real-world feel, or sometimes – just sometimes – space pyjamas. In the 1960s, colour television was all the rage and Star Trek was at the forefront of that huge leap in visual technology. It's outfits and set design were crafted to be bold and brash, resulting in the bright paintwork, scenes lit with vibrant pinks and purples and of course the now iconic division coloured uniforms. In both the planned launch of Phase II in 1978 and the earlier animated series in 1973, the iconic look of Starfleet was retained in all its bright and colourful glory. But when plans were scrapped and Paramount opted to […]

trending_flat
A Fistful of Star Trek Online’s Best Bits!

This week marks fifteen years since the launch of whats become Star Trek's most consistent and longest reigning video game, Star Trek Online. Developed following the relaunch of a new movie franchise, STO told the other side of the story. While NEro went back in time and created the Kelvin Timeline offshoot, STO focused on the galactic politics following the collapse of the Hobus Star. Customising your player character, you begin at the Academy, get yourself a star ship and rank up as you balance exploration, politics and shooting a lot of things! Over the years the game has changed and developed with expansions, new additions, rotating Executive Producers - and now new owners! - using multiple guest appearances into the mix for story mission while allowing group events, developing annual traditions and generally letting us all play with cool […]

trending_flat
Upcoming Away Missions in Glasgow & Edinburgh for the Tesla!

As we enter 2025 (or... 2402...?) there's no rest for the crew of the Tesla as the team are already back in action making a return to two of the biggest events in Scotland! One of the most active and welcoming crew, the year is already off to a flying start with more to come through the year! The first events of the year include.... Capital Sci Fi Con February 15th & 16th, O2 Academy Edinburgh Always the best way to kick start the year, Tesla is once again heading to Edinburgh for their first away mission in 2025! This years guest line up is one for the Whovians! This year the Fifth Doctor himself Peter Davidson will be in attendance for photo and autograph opportunities alongside co-star Janet Fielding, better known in the TARDIS as Fifth Doctor Companion Tegan! […]

trending_flat
Across The Universe! Black Ops Missions & Lifetime Achievements!

The year begins with a New Trek bringing us to even strange new worlds while franchise - both old and new - celebrate upcoming awards ceremonies. Section 31 Released... After a long, long wait the potentially least anticipated project in the Star Trek Universe was released on January 25th as Section 31, starring Michelle Yeoh reprising her role as reformed (kinda) Emperor Georgiou displaced in time and recruited to rejoin Section 31 for a dangerous mission to protect the Federation in the most non Federation way possible. Initially developed as a full series exploring the nature of the organisation's questionable origins and motives, the project was placed in the hands of new writers to transform the concept into a made for streaming movie as a condensed action piece that limited the original intention and replaced it with something a little […]

trending_flat
Boldly Going Nowhere: Section 31 Quick Review

REVIEW SCORE   FLEET SCORE   Focused on the outliers of the Star Trek Universe, the idea of the Section 31 film was to go beyond Starfleet and present the universe from a different perspective and in a different way. An idea thats been done with some hit and miss success over the past ten years. Section 31's initial pitch and writing team was something that had the potential to be something we could enjoy and even with mild hesitation, we were eager to see where the once series would go now a new writer had condensed the vague idea into a one off experiment, a streaming based movie to add to the tapestry of different flavours Star Trek has offered in resent years. It was also an experiment in offering a first real glimpse at a batch of heroes […]

Related

trending_flat
No One Expects The Starfleet Inquisition! Retro Review: Inquisition, DS9 S6E18

Stopped from heading to a quiet medical conference, Doctor Bashir is locked down with the crew of Deep Space Nine when internal investigations officer Sloan arrives. Apparently Deep Space Nine has a security breach. Information's being leaked to the enemy and all leads point to one person: Julian Bashir. It's a nice rarity when this era of Star Trek plays out it's story of the week without a B-Plot and Inquisition does it all quiet nicely. Especially as everything's played out from the perspective of Bashir as he's separated from his colleagues which enhances the tense paranoia of whats happening as Sloan probes through evidence that points to the doctor betraying the Federation. Thematically it's a story told many times before, even previously told in Star Trek, but with DS9's tone becoming a little darker by this stage, it worked […]

trending_flat
[Retro Review] Generations (1994)

Kirk's era my have started the phenomenon, but 1994 was a different era. Picard's Enterprise crew had just finished more than twice the amount of seasons of the original with one spin off finding it's feet and another in the pipeline. With the original crew having said their goodbyes in the Undiscovered country, the old was already out and the not quite as old were ready to take over the film branch of the Star Trek franchise. But not without a weird handover ceremony. Years after his final voyage as captain, Kirk is dragged out of retirement to sit in a chair and smile politely as a new captain launched with a new Enterprise. Of course, the new captain was typically useless so when the Enterprise was the only ship in range again, and the ship was dragged into an […]

trending_flat
[Retro Review] Schisms; TNG Season 6

Alien abduction isn't exactly an innovative or creative plot device. Long before the X Files became the most popular brand of alien conspiracy in media, we had everything from the memorably dazzling abduction in Close Encounters of the Third Kind to the found footage wonder The McPherson Tape. For Star Trek, however, it's an odd concept to include. Humanity is a space faring species and some of our best pals are aliens. If one crept into your bedroom in the middle of the night and took you on board their ship, that's more of a diplomatic nightmare than a horrific conspiracy. So when it did happen in Next Gen's Schisms it all felt a bit weird and creepy. Mostly in a good way.

trending_flat
[Retro Review] The One With The Whales (1986)

Closing off an accidental trilogy, Kirk and his disgraced crew wrap up chilling out on Vulcan to go back to Earth for a bit of a wrist slapping. While they saunter back home in a stolen Klingon ship, an alien probe pops round for tea and biscuits on Earth. Except, there's neither tea nor biscuits buit a confusing sense of chaos as it sucks everything around it of power and soaks up Earths oceans for what seems like no apparent reason.

trending_flat
[Retro Review] The Search For Spock (1984)

The Wrath of Khan was the end of the road, or so many thought. So killing off Spock was a way to close that chapter of their lives and move on to other projects. But of course, the second outing was also a success, but director Nick Meyer had a feeling it would be and put in a caveat. Before his death, Spock mind melded with Dr McCoy and told him to remember...

site2025m

Serving the fan community since 1974, SFC is an international not for profit fan organisation bringing together collective of fans collectively enjoying strange new worlds in science fiction media.

Star Trek and all related, derived or inferred ideas are the intellectual property of Paramount and Paramount Global. No infringement is intended in the use of this material. Starfleet Command Quadrant 2 (SFCQ2) does not generate any income or profit from their endeavours as a fan organisation, no part of which is sanctioned by the Paramount Global group or any sub-division of the legitimate copyright holders.

Core Website layout by Ghostpool. Managed and Maintained by Aim to Misbehave on behalf of Starfleet Command  Quadrant 2

© 2401 Starfleet  Command Quadrant 2 (SFCQ2)

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation