Over several era’s and realities within the Star Trek Universe, there are very few who can tie them all together. Kirk may have met Picard thanks to the Nexus, and Riker may have joined the crew of the Cerritos, but before those events crossed over there was one landmark event that not only helped to bridge the worlds of the original series and the Next Generation, but would begin a thread that would help spawn both the Kelvin Timeline era as well as the new revival of Star Trek.
During it’s time the Next Generation had a cameo or two from the original series. Even right at the beginning as a much older Dr McCoy, now an Admiral, had a brief scene comparing Data to his old friend Spock in the first of many “passing the torch” moments for the franchise. But with that moment being just a cameo, there was a more significant crossover three seasons later that would have a much deeper impact when Sarek, Vulcan Ambassador and father of the infamous Spock, would arrive on board the Enteprise.
Still holding onto his Vulcan dignity and upper class vibe, Sarek was ill. Losing his grip on his ability to suppress emotions and in need of aides to help him stay strong. Eventually, to carry out his diplomatic mission, he’d mind meld with Picard and leave the Captain with all the emotional trauma and rage so Sarek could hold onto his mind long enough to fulfil his duties. As they parted ways, Picard not only experienced the intensity of a supresed Vulcan emotion, but learned Sarek’s love for his son, Spock and the deep regret he had for logic interfering in showing love.
In Season 5 Sarek would return one last time as his son was missing. Last seen on Romulus, the Federation feared their Ambassador had defected to the enemy. With a long lifetimes of secrets and knowledge, Spocks insight into the Federation would be a deadly weapon that could be used against them and a huge betrayal. Sarek knew the truth however, telling Picard that Spock had something more pressing on Romulus. A desire to end the conflicts between them and Vulcan and bring the two species – who shared a common ancestry – back into one nation.
Months before Leonard Nimoy would return alongside William Shatner and Deforest Kelley for their final film appearance together, Spock would preface the end of his era by joining the Next Generation cast as Picard began a whole different kind of search for Spock!
The two parter is more complex than just “Spocks in it!” as many remember it for. It’s also a little frustration as the first part only had Nimoy appearing in the closing scenes as a big reveal to bring on the second part. In terms of how the story plays out, Spock’s just part of the potential power shift within the episodes. Once Picard finds out the possibility of Spock just pushing for his goal of bringing peace with Romulus, it branches out into two core threads; one with Picard and Data putting on their best Romulan cosplay and making their way to Romulus with the help of some Klingon pals, and the other with Riker taking command of the Enterprise to follow a mystery as he tracks down the origin of some suspicious debris.
On Riker’s side of things, despite chasing what looks to be a nefarious plot involving the trademark deceptive Romulans, there’s a lot of fun moments along the way. Mainly with the stereotypically grumpy junkyard superviser throwing his authority around while sitting atop a vast fleet of completely dead and useless starships. It’s a cliché scene of sheer arrogance, but offers a bigger smile than Riker going all bad ass on a bit of a weak challenge when chasing his next clue.
Picard’s journey has a bit of humour as well. Their Klingon escort, played by Stephen Root who’s far better known for being the awkward weirdo in things like Dodgeball, takes his time in relishing putting Picard through severe discomfort in a spartan, comfort free cabin built for hardened warriors who’s rather sleep on a metal shelf instead of a nice comfy bed. And of course sharing a room with Data who just stands in the middle of the room staring into space as Picard fails to sleep knowing Data’s right behind him like an intrusive man-shaped baby monitor.
GENERATIONS PAST
Under the moments of levity, the plot’s actually one of the better ones when it comes to Romulan intrigue and fit in nicely to the shenanigans that surrounded Sela. Despite that, the first part does drag a bit. It’s just one big waiting game, putting all the blocks in place for the final scenes where Spock wanders out of the shadows and the core of the story begins.
The best part of the first half happens early on. And thats all Sarek. After seeing him earlier in the series, showing the wise old Vulcan’s brain was beginning to fall apart like a wet cake, it was an emotional moment. Having seen Picard suffer through the Vulcan rage of emotion following their season 3 mind meld, as well was watching Sarek desperately try to cling on, that original appearance was already a tough watch for such a character. Here, it hit even harder.
Quite literally on his deathbed, Sarek couldn’t hide his instability any longer. He was at the end of the road and there was no effort to pretend otherwise. Both Patrick Stewart and Mark Lenard were on top of their game in portraying their shared pain, having bonded significantly through the meld. Later on we learn Sarek does die off screen shortly after this scene which leaves Picard with the heavy burden of having the last remnant of Sarek in his mind; all the more important a reason to find Spock and share the love and admiration Sarek always repressed.
It adds a real weight to the episode that other aspects don’t. Which isn’t a huge criticism. Picard taking a trip and Riker chasing down stolen scrap isn’t exactly captivating viewing with a lot of room for drama. Though the tension throughout builds nicely until Data and Picard manage to crack the code of the secret underground Spock fans on Romulus. Which is quite a surprise considering Federation types are unwelcome, there’s a massive city on a massive planet and within an incredibly secretive society. Yet… an easy task. No wonder Garak spent time there…
Looking back now this just seems to be another journey for Spock as we catch up with his 24th century self. It all fits. When it was first broadcast, this was a month before the final original cast film would have their last hurrah. The Undiscovered Country would see Spock begin his transition from occasional science officer, Academy instructor, mentor and problem solver to the diplomat presented in TNG. As the son of Vulcan’s ambassador to Earth, he’d begin to take up the mantle and push for peace with the Klingons. Here his main goal is to find peace with Romulus, or at least shine enough oof a light on the idea that the process can begin to bring them and Vulcans together, remember their ancestral roots and start the journey.
Romulans being Romulans though, you know something’s not right. A lot of it’s telegraphed with Rikers side of things. While Spock has some up and coming politicians in his little peace cult, people he believe can lead the way if and when they find their seat of power, Riker’s following mysterious stolen Vulcan derelicts and a transport ship thats stealing supplies from the junkyard depot.
You can kind of see it all coming together. Spock’s hope and faith that peace can be achieved blinds him to the truth of the situation. He’s got two big players on board, Neral and Pardek. And Picard is rightly suspicious of how far Spocks come in such a short space of time and how easy it was to turn people within a conservative and insular structure. And of course, it all goes wrong. Never trust a Romulan. But thats the exact same sentiment Spock would argue against in his last mission on board the Enterprise. He was the voice of reason when prejudice overwhelmed everyone. With the Klingons, he was right. Here, it was far, far too soon.
Spocks supposed closest ally on Romulus, Neral, isn’t quite what he appears to be. He assures Spock that he can convince the other senior members of government to come along to Spocks line of thinking, to lean towards peace. He was a trap that Spock fell right into. Pardek was planning to capture and use Spock, to twist his ideas into a fake peace statement and use the distraction to send all those stolen Vulcan ships – refitted and now heavily armed – to strike on Vulcan. This is all the masterplan of power hungry half-Romulan paradox child Sela who’ll make her last appearance here.
LOGICAL CONCLUSION
In terms of plot, it’s typically devious of the Romulans but particularly terrible in execution. Which is a big writing flaw. From the cliché of Sela Bond Villianing her plan by exposing every single detail, neglecting to lock them up and only sending a handful of troops to invade an entire planet, she looks like a complete idiot. They obviously overthrow her and she finds herself ion her most final of defeats after a few appearances.
All the twists and turns are expected. We know from the start theres something odd going on, and Romulans are involved. From there you can guess the ending before it even plays out. Creatively it’s nothing special, other than Leonard Nimoy agreed to come on board as a promotional tactic ahjead of the Undiscovered Country’s release. To the point where he lowered his fee from a million to the going rate to make it work.
For the first major crossover for Star Trek, the story could have been better. And it doesn’t make anyone look good. From Spock not seeing the obvious, to Sarek dying off screen. There were little bits and pieces that would and could have been tightened or re-planned to heighten the drama. And for it’s big scope and political ramifications – both of Romulus trying to invade Vulcan, to Spock’s mission of peace – it feels a little underplayed.
On the flip side, underwhelming main plot aside, this really is a character piece. Now Sarek has passed, Spock has to contend with his fathers provisioning logic, a cautious wisdom Spock knows would reject and challenge his plan. But now through both his meld with Sarek, as well as his own wisdom and caution, Picard steps into that role to challenge Spock, making a unique and well played dynamic between the two iconic characters.
This also stands as an introduction for the Spock we would see in the Undiscovered Country, one that would see logic as a stepping stone and no longer a constant to base his every decision off. There’s a more open mindedness that comes with maturity, a Spock who’s fully embraced both of his conflicting halves. For the lackluster story, those scenes with Nimoy and Stewart together – ass well as a nice and completely unavoidable scene where Spock chats with the new Enterprise logician, Data – makes up for the otherwise average episode.
For it’s flaws, this is an episode that would have a bizarrely lasting legacy. Spocks ties to the Romulans would continue well belong the Next Generation era. Determined to save Romulus from a world-ending event, he’d prove the Federation could be good allies, get lost in time and help start the Kelvin Timeline. Which in turn would also lead to the events surrounding Star Trek: Picards first season. And of course, eventually his plan to unify Romulus and Vulcan would come to be as by the 32nd century, his foster sister Michael Burnham would see a scene from this episode replayed to her after learning of the Unification process.
For an average episode, it’s an episode thats become a significant part of the tapestry of the Star Trek Universe. As the first major crossover, and a significantly better one than Scotty being found in a transporter beam, it was a bigger event during 1991 than it is on a Netflix binge. It’s lack of logic within the plot does take the shine off it a little when looking back on it with fresh eyes. But having Picard and Spock in the same room, as well as the flashpoint it’s become in the grand scheme of things, it is worth a rewatch at least once!
Our next Retro Review is going back to another crossover episode as we take a trip into Tuvok’s Vulcan mind where he takes Captain Janeway on a trip down memory lane to his first tour in Starfleet. Interjecting Tuvok and his Captain into the events of the Undiscovered Country, Voyager celebrates 30 years of Star Trek on board the USS Excelsior with Captain Sulu…
About the author
It’s Not Easy Being Green Blooded: ‘Level Five Transporter Accident’, Strange New Worlds S4E05
Spock's going through a bit of a personal crisis and Scotty's become madly competitive with an old Academy rival. These two separate threads collide in the weirdest way when Spock finds himself as the only person who can control the ship as Scotty's transporter antics turn everyone into puppets... Writers: Henry Alonso Myers & Dana HorganDirector: Jordan Canning Spock's not quite feeling himself and he hasn't quite been himself since the Griffin Incident. And things are getting worse. Leaning heavily towards logic over his exploration of his human side, and in the wake of La'an deciding their relationship had reached it's 'natural conclusion', he's spiraling. Well, as much as a Vulcan would allow themselves to. Desperately trying to balance himself, he's leaning into logic and reaching out to his scorned ex-fiancee for help in re-establishing his Vulcan side.While thats happening, Scotty's on a […]
1701 Shades of Grey: ‘A Case of Chiaroscuro’, Strange New Worlds S4E04
It's been a stressful few months for the Enterprise crew and they want, well, demand, shore leave. Choosing a tech-free planet with natural psychedelics in the atmosphere, the command crew take a shuttle down, take in all the wonders the world provides. And then it all goes a bit wonky... Writers: Skylar Ojeda & Dana Horgan Director: Meera Menon Aside from orbiting a star who's radiation gives an altered perspective of light, Mat'aar XII is a world occupied by Klingon overlords. Having taken control of the population, and implemented strict monitoring and restrictions on movement, the Klingon's rule with fear, torture and by creating division. Like any good occupiers, they've given cushy jobs to some locals including their top Lieutenant, Navatte, a local who proudly wears her silver Klingon armband and interrogates anyone who oppose the Empire. Or so […]
[Departmental] Introducing General Board
The General Board is a relatively new concept and the next evolution of Fleet Support. Mirroring the Captains Table, the General Board is constructed to help overall fleet operations and to contribute more voices and ideas to the clubs operation. Based very loosely on the political 'two house' structure, and named after the real-world General Board within the US Navy in the first half of the 20th century, the starting point was to appoint two sets of voices within the fleet. The Captains represent their unit and their members need within that unit, each representing an area or group that makes up the whole. To contrast and add to the Captains Table, Fleet Support – and now the expanded General Board – allows to give both opinions of fleet leadership and fleet membership equal standing and ensure we hear a […]
Welcoming Our New Fleet Development Officer
To quote Heraclitus, the only constant in life is change. Quadrant 2 has been through many changes before and with the recent appointment of a new Admiralty Board, we're looking ahead with more changes to the fleet structure. With Piers Drinkall joining the board alongside David Shires, there were some discussions about what to do with Piers' Fleet Development role and after some serious thinking, a decision was made. After aiding in Piers' efforts within the Command Training Program, and being a solid right hand on the USS Sovereign, we're pleased to welcome Karl Drinkall to the Fleet Development position. Karl is a sharp mind with a lot to give to the fleet and a clear grasp of our aims and goals in the coming months and years. With his dedication and string mindset, it was an easy decision to […]
[Retro Review] Errand of Mercy
Relations between the Federation and the Klingons are in tatters and the prospect of an all out war casts a shadow over the region. To help prepare for the worst, Kirk and the Enterprise are sent to Organia, a planet populated by inherent pushovers right on the border between Federation and Klingon space. With the prospect of the Klingons getting a foothold that would help their war efforts, Kirk's job is to negotiate a protection order, getting the Organians on their side before the Klingons annexe the planet as a launching pad for conflict. Problem is, the Organians are hardcore pacifists and their native tech is limited. They don't want to be part of any war, and they don't want to change their values to resist. Which becomes a bit of a problem when the Klingons arrive ready to occupy the […]
Dude, Where’s Your Shuttle? Human Best Friend; Strange New Worlds S4E03
It's been a stressful few months for the Enterprise crew and they want, well, demand, shore leave. Choosing a tech-free planet with natural psychedelics in the atmosphere, the command crew take a shuttle down, take in all the wonders the world provides. And then it all goes a bit wonky... Writers: Kathryn LynDirector: Yana Gorskaya Engineers and pilots hate each other. It's the rules. Scotty and Ortegas have been following those rules to the letter, with the bickering pair opening with a dual monologue highlighting how irritating they are to each other between Scotty setting up alerts and alarms to keep the engines in check, and Ortegas duct tapping over the console to get rid of them so she can push the limits freely.While they're constantly irritating each other, the rest of the Alpha shift command team are exhausted. Months […]
Related
[Retro Review] Errand of Mercy
Relations between the Federation and the Klingons are in tatters and the prospect of an all out war casts a shadow over the region. To help prepare for the worst, Kirk and the Enterprise are sent to Organia, a planet populated by inherent pushovers right on the border between Federation and Klingon space. With the prospect of the Klingons getting a foothold that would help their war efforts, Kirk's job is to negotiate a protection order, getting the Organians on their side before the Klingons annexe the planet as a launching pad for conflict. Problem is, the Organians are hardcore pacifists and their native tech is limited. They don't want to be part of any war, and they don't want to change their values to resist. Which becomes a bit of a problem when the Klingons arrive ready to occupy the […]
[Retro Review] The Galileo Seven
Pulled in two directions, the Enterprise has to deliver critical medical supplies to avert a plague and conduct vital research at the same time. Unable to turn down the order, Kirk thinks on his feet by carrying forward to save the planet, while sending Spock to lead a research team on the Galileo shuttle to carry out their mission until the Enterprise has finished it's mission of mercy. It's a good idea. Until it isn't. Isolated form the Enterprise, the Galileo runs into a bit of bother. Thrown off course by plot, the shuttle crash lands on a primitive planet. Alone with a broken ship and a people who are as barbaric as they are terrified by the shuttles sudden arrival, Spock has to lead his own team through fear and frustration with cool and calming logic. On the first […]
[Retro Review] Space Seed
By chance, the Enterprise comes across an ancient Earth ship drifting through space. On board they find a whole bunch of people held in suspended animation, wake up the leader of the gang and accidentally unleash one of the most iconic villains of the franchise. Being coy with his identity at first, ship historian Marla McGivers becomes fascinated with a glimpse at the past while Kirk and the rest of the non-historians figure out that he just happens to be one of the most notorious war lords in Earths history... Star Trek, Season 1 , Episode 22 For all the action and adventure of deep space and the idea of using alien make up to mask more down to earth stories, Space Seed gives the first real glimpse of Star Trek's history. Khan is a relic of Earth from long […]
[Retro Review] Let This Be Your Last Battlefield
Often shown in highlight reels and quoted in discussions about Star Trek's more forward thinking messages, Let This Be Your Last Battlefield is at it's simplest, a story of the ridiculousness of segregation. En route to a vital mission of mercy, Kirk and his crew end up in the middle of a political minefield. Interrupted in the mission by a stolen Federation shuttle carrying an injured alien, Lokai from the planet Cheron, they're soon further interrupted by Commissioner Bele, an official representing Cheron who announces Lokai as a political traitor and demanding custody. One asylum request later, Kirk's stuck between the two trying to find the right course of action knowing he has orders to follow beyond the situation. The separation between Belle and Lokai is a simple context. And also a strangely charged one looking at it from a […]
[Retro Review] The Trouble With Tribbles
Space adventures, time travelling madness and the occasional God was standard fare for the original series. But every now and then it dived into a mission of the mundane. Kirk's mission in The Trouble With Tribbles is as dull as it could be and he's hugely aware of it. The Klingon's have popped up again and the people of resupply station K7 want some help guarding a huge shipment of grain. As the Klingons ask for shore leave, they share the station with the Enterprise crew while Kirk tries to keep his cool... For decades now this is one of those episodes that jumped out and added one of the weirdest parts to the Star Trek lore. Tribbles. Introduced by trader Cyrano Jones, the inoffensive little balls of fur catch the attention of Uhura who buys one instantly and takes […]
[Retro Review] Balance of Terror.
Each era of Star Trek has captured a moment in time. The original series captured as unique a moment as any that feels both like ancient history and something that still resonates. It's cast and writers still felt the effects of the second world war, from actors like James Doohan who was famously injured in D-Day, to producer Robert Justman among the many on board the Enterprise who's lives were in part shaped by the historical event. At the same time, much as things are today, there was no end to conflict or instability in the world and even the race to the moon and seeing Apollo 11's flight suffered the dark cloud of the cold war between the United States and what was then the USSR. The background and setting behind the era was what could create episodes like […]
