Since it’s launch as Star Trek’s new flagship show in 2017, Star Trek Discovery has made an effort to reinvent itself year by year to tell new stories with new styles and themes. Each season being it’s own new mission, the crew began as distrustful strangers under the command of a cold tactician to living in the far future trying to restore the Federation into the utopia of it’s prime.
It’s not been smooth sailing for the show. Behind the scene’s the first season saw it’s creator depart, leaving his closest collaborators to take the helm and critical commentary online has saw fan arguments from large narrative complaints to nitpicking about the sets being too ‘advanced’ for starting off ten years before Kirk’s 1960’s designed Enterprise.
Still the show has had it’s successes, both creatively thanks to some bold choices including focusing on a character who wasn’t Captain for the first time, to real world successes. Primarily being heralded for being the most diverse Star Trek show to date as well as making the launch of CBS All Access (Now Paramount+) such a large success that Star Trek exploded to the point where we had five separate seasons in productions at once.
It’s not a show for everyone and it’s approach has changed massively from it’s chaotic first season. But it’s brought a lot to the Star Trek Universe from new technologies, new lore and now a whole new exploration of the Federation further ahead in time than anything we’d seen before. It’s also been a huge journey where the cast have grown and changed from their first appearance, Burnham at the core as she’s gone from disgraced mutineer to Captain while her once rival Saru grew with her to become her closest friend and advisor.
Looking ahead to the fifth and final season launching this month, we’ve been having a rewatch and picked out the five standouts for the show so far.
Magic To Make The Sanest Man Go Mad
Season 1, Episode 7
To kick off, why not focus on a one off story in the middle of a serialised arc? Rainn Wilson’s Harry Mudd was introduced earlier in the season as a dodgy fella selling out Lorca and Ash Tyler to the Klingons. Here he returns for some comedy value as a bit of a cool-down in the middle of a tense story. Afrter being outmanoeuvred by Lorca during their time sharing a cell on a Klingon ship, Mudd finds Discovery and plays Groundhog Day to fiond a way to take the ship and sell it to the enemy.
Of course he fails. Otherwise there wouldn’t be any more episodes after that. But in a season that brings in some very dark plots, and even an episode that tries to solidify Michael Burnham breaking out of her shell and trying to find a human connection with Ash Tyler, it’s a wonderfully ridiculous story breaking up a lot of dark and troubling threads that still managed to act as one of Discovery’s few self isolated arcs.
Unification Part III
Season 3, Episode 7
Flinging Discovery into the far future let us have a glimpse of what Starfleet would (or wouldn’t) be 900 years in the future. It wasn’t all good, and not everyone was still part of the big Federation family. Narratively Season 3 has some issues. For a show built on surprise, it seemed to avoid any tension and burst the bubble of a mystery before we could even acknowledge it. On the other hand, the big controversial event it investigated annoyed people despite some wonderful performances and a classic sci fi trope coming to the forefront.
Unification Part III didn’t take the massive risks it could have, nor the risks the rest of the season had. But it brought together two eras of Star Trek very nicely. Burnham and Spock last saw each before he’d even met Kirk nor crafted his legacy. In this episode, she saw her adoptive brother in his elder years as a passionate advocate of peace. Seeing the results of that Next Gen two parter alongside Discovery’s own past was perfect unification of creative ideas and plans.
]Brother
Season 2, Episode 1
If Discovery is good at one thing, it’s reinventing itself. It’s debut season was filled with tension, twists and keeping the audience on it’s toes. Part of that came with the secret Terran Captain Lorca and the sense of distrust his crew had in him. Season two started with an instant shift in tone by introducing the barely seen legendary Captain Pike, predecessor to fellow legend Jim Kirk, taking command of Discovery with a firm hand and friendly attitude.
As a change of course, Brother works wonderfully. It’s not quite Way of Rthe Warrior in re-inventing the show, but it builds on Burnham’s background with Sarek and Spock – teasing the latter appearance as a missing science officer not on the Enterprise – replaces the suspect Lorca with a paternal Pike making a point of bringing ease to a troubled crew and brings a whole new mystery all at once. We even get a resdhirt death. Sure, he’s a science officer, but we knew it was coming! By the end of season one the crew were beginning to come together.
In Brother, we finally get a glimpse of what they can be under a leader who’s not a complete and utter psychopath; and makes the show all the better for it.
Such Sweet Sorrow
Season 2, Episodes 13 & 14
Mirroring Brother, Season 2 ended just as well as it started. Sure, there were moments that seemed mental. Battle raging on, race against time and yet Spock and Burnham still have time for a few heart to hearts? Priorities people! But overall there was a real sense of excitement and urgency that always see’s Discovery at it’s finest and hadn’t been seen since, well… thats for later.
Theres a finality to the episode. The season had it’s ups and downs. From callbacks to Pike’s original unaired story from 1964 to Saru maturing beyond what he was told he could be, to bringing in Burnhams dear old not dead mum as the mysterious Red Angel. And it all ends with some classic sci fi evil AI, Control, taking over Secion 31 ships and going into a fight to the death with Discovery and Enterprise side by side.
There’s a lot going on in this episode. Some parts remind me of classic Trek. Some remind me of the films. Some reminds me of Battlestar Galactica considering we have a dogfight in space. But overall it gives a shot of adrenaline not many Star Trek finale’s have had. We have science as we go through a plan to lead Discovery into the far future. We have action in a tense – and wonderfully done – fight against Control. We have L’Rell racing to support peace in a complete 180 from her original mission in season one. And we have emotional beats from Spock and Burnham saying their final goodbyes to Admiral Cornwell getting a heroes death.
The Season 2 finale was a packed ending that not only delivered a neatly wrapped conclusion to the story, but to the 23rd century for the show. Better still, while we learn nothing about what happened to Discovery after the crew take a leap to the future, but the epilogue showing Pike, Spock and Number One on the Enterprise would eventually lead to Discovery’s first spin off, Strange New Worlds.
Into the Forest I Go
Season 1, Episode 9
Season 1’s arc goes in many multiple directions and a story told in two halves with an underlying theme of the first half being… who exactly is Gabriel Lorca? Unlike any captain who’s came before him in Star Trek, Lorca is a far colder and more militaristic mind than the likes of Kirk or even Sisko. From his first introduction Stamets’ calls him a war monger and despite being in charge of a highly specialised science ship, his motivations had always been questionable. While a few did come round to his ways, particularly Burnham as she came to understand his way of thinking, Stamets was always the hard sell. This was the episode Lorca won the astromicologist over and lived to regret it….
For the most part, until this point, Star Trek hadn’t done a lot of serialised story telling. This was the first episode in Discovery that showed how well things could work when everything comes together. Lorca and Stamets’ meeting of the minds over using the Spore Drive against the Klingons is just one piece of the puzzle, and a moment that would pay off for the rest of the season. We also saw another character with a question mark over his head, Ash Tyler, have a PSTD related breakdown while on a mission with Burnham to plant sensors on Kol’s stolen ship; a moment that would make Ash realise he wasn’t who he believed he was; reaching right back to the opening episode before he’#d even arrived on Discovery.
Burnham herself got some progression. She was never able to save Captain Georgiou, but by defeating Kol and his ship, which had become an icon in itself for the Klingon’s new unity, she was able to put right at least one of her wrongs and take back Georgiou’s Starfleet pin, worn as a mark of Pride by the Klingon General.
Outwith the larger story arcs being closed off and moved forward for the second half, a singular episode the threads flow seamlessly together to bring out one of the best written episodes of the first season. Plus there’s some fantastic action that helps keep the flow of the episode as Discovery makes over a hundred jumps around the Sarcophagus while the ground team infiltrates the ship to find a way around the cloaking technology.
By the end everyones happy and united which between the first batch of episodes and the work done here, feels very much earned as we close out with Lorca and Stamets standing side by side with the Captain asking for one last spore jump home. A jump that teases this isn’t the happy ending we think it is as Discovery finds itself lost, alone and about to enter a whole new world of trouble…
Whether the criticism of Discovery is fair or unfair, episodes like this one made the first season something really special. With Discovery following a more balanced and toned down nature since it’s third season, Into The Forest I Go is a wonderful example of the energy and excitement the show had in it’s chaotic first year.
About the author
[Retro Review] The Galileo Seven
Pulled in two directions, the Enterprise has to deliver critical medical supplies to avert a plague and conduct vital research at the same time. Unable to turn down the order, Kirk thinks on his feet by carrying forward to save the planet, while sending Spock to lead a research team on the Galileo shuttle to carry out their mission until the Enterprise has finished it's mission of mercy. It's a good idea. Until it isn't. Isolated form the Enterprise, the Galileo runs into a bit of bother. Thrown off course by plot, the shuttle crash lands on a primitive planet. Alone with a broken ship and a people who are as barbaric as they are terrified by the shuttles sudden arrival, Spock has to lead his own team through fear and frustration with cool and calming logic. On the first […]
A Fistful of O’Brien
Entering the Star Trek world as an unnamed extra with a few bits of dialogue, O'Brien soon became a fixture on the Enterprise D as it's transporter chief before moving to Deep Space Nine to head up engineering and operations on what was thought to be a backwater outpost before it became one of the most strategically important stations in the quadrant!As the only enlisted or non commissioned officer to feature in the main cast of any Star Trek show to date, O'Brien stands as the only working class hero in the Star Trek universe with a vast and varied career taking from the front lines of the Cardassian war as a soldier, to the front lines of the Dominion War as an engineer, retrofitting DS9, keeping the Defiant from blowing itself apart, and even sniping Dominion troops. All in […]
[Q2&A] Career Track
SFC has always structured it's internal reward and recognition system on the command structure of Starfleet on screen. Newbies are cadets. When they become full members, they become Ensigns. And those eager to take on a leadership role can rank up to Commander or Captain. Even the board of directors are mirrored within the theme as Commodores and Admirals! It's always been the way, but the path of an officer isn't for everyone... Despite the original idea of all star ship personnel being highly trained astronauts, therefore nullifying the need for enlisted crew, the enlisted ranks have existed in some form since the original series. More defined in the film era, particularly under the revision of style and structure in The Wrath of Khan, they have been slightly more prominent since. Most notable of the enlisted members of Starfleet was […]
[Retro Review] Space Seed
By chance, the Enterprise comes across an ancient Earth ship drifting through space. On board they find a whole bunch of people held in suspended animation, wake up the leader of the gang and accidentally unleash one of the most iconic villains of the franchise. Being coy with his identity at first, ship historian Marla McGivers becomes fascinated with a glimpse at the past while Kirk and the rest of the non-historians figure out that he just happens to be one of the most notorious war lords in Earths history... Star Trek, Season 1 , Episode 22 For all the action and adventure of deep space and the idea of using alien make up to mask more down to earth stories, Space Seed gives the first real glimpse of Star Trek's history. Khan is a relic of Earth from long […]
Resistance Is Optional: Choose Your Adventure!
Our trials of bringing the fleet together have been hit and miss with scheduling and dates being a bit slim. So we're opening the floor to the fleet to pick the next date and theme! You can make your selection below on what works best for you ahead of our next fleet event! The final outcome will be shared at Europa on Facebook and in Fleet Alert in the Officers Hub as soon as we have a comfortable number of notes. For more information or to get direct updates on non-Discord online events, you can the subscribe to Twitch channel, visit twitch.tv/sfcq2. Google Meets events are hosted by our google account - you can add sfcquad2@gmail.com to your whitelist to ensure direct notification. Info and invite confirmations may also come from jt@sfcq2.com directly.
Sixty Year Mission…
It's been a really weird year already for the world of Star Trek fans. We started 2026 with a new venture into a strange new future with Starfleet Academy. Then just as the show had won people over, we found out it's the latest in a long list of recent productions to get a cancellation order, is a bit of a weird way to start the 60th anniversary of a legendary franchise. The past few years we've kind of spoiled. Growing up it was exciting to have Deep Space Nine run alongside the Next Generation. In modern times we had multiple shows going at once with Discovery's launch spawning a new world of story telling from revisiting Picard in his post-Starfleet years, to animated comedy with Lower Decks, to finally telling the story of Captain Pike and even a peek […]
Related
A Fistful of O’Brien
Entering the Star Trek world as an unnamed extra with a few bits of dialogue, O'Brien soon became a fixture on the Enterprise D as it's transporter chief before moving to Deep Space Nine to head up engineering and operations on what was thought to be a backwater outpost before it became one of the most strategically important stations in the quadrant!As the only enlisted or non commissioned officer to feature in the main cast of any Star Trek show to date, O'Brien stands as the only working class hero in the Star Trek universe with a vast and varied career taking from the front lines of the Cardassian war as a soldier, to the front lines of the Dominion War as an engineer, retrofitting DS9, keeping the Defiant from blowing itself apart, and even sniping Dominion troops. All in […]
A Fistful of Justice
Although it's one of the worlds most legendary science fiction shows, Star Trek has always dabbled with format and genre's, all dressed up behind deep space adventures. Whether using the holodeck for a touch of fantasy, or diving into the horrors of war through Deep Space Nine's run, the variety of story telling never seems to fit one mould. But out of all the different tales told in the wonderful world of Starfleet, one that always promises to deliver is the court room drama. This month we're diving into the most captivating of Star Trek's courtroom drama's with a Fistful of Justice! AD ASTRA PER ASPERA Strange New Worlds, Season 2 One of the most modern examples of Strar Trek's court room drama saw Pike's own Number One, Una-Chin Reilly, under court martial for a serious breach of Starfleet regulation […]
A Fistful of Sisko
In the past few years, Star Trek has made several nods to it's past. But while The NExt Generation and Voyager had their continuations, Deep Space Nine continued to 'black sheep' of the family with it's history and name drops being few and far between. Until Academy when we had an entire episode based around the legend of Starfleet's most complex captains. Starting his show as a widower and single parent, Benjamin Sisko started his time in Star Trek as a reluctant hero turned religious icon who's become a prime figure in Bajoran history, the Federation-Dominion war and much more. If you missed his series, first of.... why?! And also, if you want a quick intro - here's our Sisko top five to see what the fuss is all about. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzBkvzPoofQ IN THE PALE MOONLIGHT Season 6, Episode 13 Lets […]
A Fistful of Honour Beyond Bloodshed
Feared throughout the galaxy due to being fearless warriors who thrive on battle and bloodshed, the Klingon's are one of Star Trek's most iconic races and yet, with all their history, perhaps the most misunderstood. Starting off in the original series as authoritarian and distrustful antagonist, they were written as a parallel to Russia with the Klingon Empire in a cold war with the Federation following a long conflict. The Klingons would have a bit of reinvention in the movies thanks to higher budgets giving the producers a chance for a more alien look, while their culture and history would get a little more depth on The Next Generation thanks to the inclusion of Worf, the first Klingon member of Starfleet. But Worf's views on the Klingon culture weren't quite spot on. From a noble house, Worf was displaced and […]
A Fistful of Familiar Surroundings
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. President Forward During the Next Generation multiple set pieces were re-used and recycled from the set pieces built for the film franchise. From the obvious re-use of internal corridors, to smaller pieces such as Dr Crushers office being McCoy's, it's hard for a keen eye to ignore how much the productions shared between them. But as The Next Generation became the dominant forcer with ongoing production and full standing sets, eventually the turn tabled and by the final original cast instalment, it was the TNG stages that became the obvious redress solution. The most jarring of the films set re-uses was the office of the president. As Kirk and McCoy were charged with assassination, a political poop show begins and the Federation […]
A Fistful of New Beginnings
The coming of a new year always comes with a feeling of new beginnings. Whether it's hearing the bells at midnight or planning a list of new years resolutions to forget about by February, the changing of numbers and another year ahead can bring us a sense of starting over. To commemorate another year passing, and the beginning of a new Star Trek milestone, we're kicking off with our usual list looking at five times Star Trek itself was able to give itself a fresh start. GROWING THE BEARD Between the first and second seasons of The Next Generation, things changed. A lot. A lot of the Next Generation was just carrying over from the abandoned Phase II and Roddenberry's constant rewrites led to a very inconsistent start for the show. By the second season things has calmed down a […]
