Background

[Review] Red Directive/Under The Twin Moons (Discovery S5, E1&2)

Article arrow_drop_down

aunching as a two part story, Discovery’s final season looks to be reinventing itself for the last time by dropping all the background drama for a more uplifting mission this time round. Where last season felt like things were settling down – perhaps a little too quickly – with the Species 10C story bringing together the fractured factions of the Federation past and present, the story veered more into the style of classic slow-burn sci fi.

In just two episodes it feels like they’re ready to do what Discovery’s always done best while doing something it’s largely avoided; following another mystery but this time finding the time to have fun. So far the 32nd century feels very sombre, not helped by a pacing that mirrored films like Contact or even The Motion Picture itself. Within the opening moments it feels like the shows ready to embrace the action and fun we’d seen back in Season 2 as it kick started with a flash of Burnham clinging onto a ship as it races through deep space with a grin on her face despite almost dying.

During the run up to the season premiere both cast and crew used “Indiana Jones” as a comparison. Just watching the opening scene, it was an obvious inspiration and almost homage to Indy racing across the train in Dial of Destiny and in the flashbacks of Indy’s youth in The Last Crusade.

Following the trend, the two episodes lay the groundwork for a mission Henry Jones Jr would instantly sign up for while digging up Star Trek’s own past. Which is actually quite impressive. Not by the premise, but for how up front they are about the mystery this time. While previous seasons would let things linger this one pulls up the file straight away. Once upon a time Captain Picard and other explorers discovered a race they called the Progenitors; an ancient people who spread life throughout the galaxy. This means many species had the same starting point and an ancient genetic marker, giving a link between humans, Klingons, Romulans and more.

In the Next Generation episode’ The Chase’, several factions raced to find the answer to Professor Galen’s (Picards mentor) work. The episodic nature of the show meant that we got to this massive revelation that there was a genetic family that linked half the known galaxy and it never came up again. Until now. That revelation was buried in time and now, centuries later, the mysterious knower of nearly everything Dr Kovich is sending Burnham on a quest to find a Romulan scientists work and recover the technology of the race that started everything.

A mysterious ancient relic? A hung to find it while questionable characters are also looking for the same thing? Yeah. Thats pure Indy Jones. And I kind of love it. What I love more is that for once we’re not teasing the starting point. Bucking the trend of hiding a secret in plain sight, the first two episodes throw out the big answer: What we’re looking for. Who this race is. We even get a skip to the end recap with a picture of Picard as well.

While each episode has it’s own strengths and weaknesses, it’s hard to separate them as they both serve to set up the season. We recap where the characters are – from Stamets feeling irrelevant due to his Spore Drive now being made redundant to Tilly coming on board as a temp with significantly more confident. Even Book getting dragged back works after betraying Burnham. It’s not just her emotional ties to him, but the fact the other group looking for the artifacts are rouges just like him. Insight aplenty.

Also joining the team is Captain Raynor, a bit of a rogue himself who tried to better Burnham and loses everything. Who would seem fascinating as an addition to replace Saru, who’s joining the diplomatic arm of the Federation in order to be closer to T’Rina, but despite the series not having plans to wrap up at the time it was filmed, there is a finality in it all. It might be some post-cancellation editing, but it all feels like one last wild ride while seeding final challenges and happy endings.

Together the episodes deliver a lot of fun showing a lighter direction that Season 4, and just lay the groundwork very clearly to expand on an untouched bit of Star Trek lore. Some stuff feels there for the cool factor – like how to stop a rock slide! – and some stuff feels a little convoluted. Saru made a point about second chances, but Raynor still seems a bit of a dick when where are better options for XO

But overall this merged the best of both worlds. The insanity of overpowered 32nd century world building, while reinjecting Discovery with a sense of joy that seemed to have been sterilised with the jump to the future.

About the author

About the author

ADM JT Marczynka, DoFA

Creator of things, writer of words, caffeine addict. Director of Communications for Starfleet Command Quadrant 2.

More posts Follow

trending_flat
Resistance Is Optional: Choose Your Adventure!

Our trials of bringing the fleet together have been hit and miss with scheduling and dates being a bit slim. So we're opening the floor to the fleet to pick the next date and theme! You can make your selection below on what works best for you ahead of our next fleet event! The final outcome will be shared at Europa on Facebook and in Fleet Alert in the Officers Hub as soon as we have a comfortable number of notes. For more information or to get direct updates on non-Discord online events, you can the  subscribe to Twitch channel, visit twitch.tv/sfcq2. Google Meets events are hosted by our google account - you can add sfcquad2@gmail.com to your whitelist to ensure direct notification. Info and invite confirmations may also come from jt@sfcq2.com directly.

trending_flat
Sixty Year Mission…

It's been a really weird year already for the world of Star Trek fans. We started 2026 with a new venture into a strange new future with Starfleet Academy. Then just as the show had won people over, we found out it's the latest in a long list of recent productions to get a cancellation order, is a bit of a weird way to start the 60th anniversary of a legendary franchise. The past few years we've kind of spoiled. Growing up it was exciting to have Deep Space Nine run alongside the Next Generation. In modern times we had multiple shows going at once with Discovery's launch spawning a new world of story telling from revisiting Picard in his post-Starfleet years, to animated comedy with Lower Decks, to finally telling the story of Captain Pike and even a peek […]

trending_flat
[Retro Review] Let This Be Your Last Battlefield

Often shown in highlight reels and quoted in discussions about Star Trek's more forward thinking messages, Let This Be Your Last Battlefield is at it's simplest, a story of the ridiculousness of segregation. En route to a vital mission of mercy, Kirk and his crew end up in the middle of a political minefield. Interrupted in the mission by a stolen Federation shuttle carrying an injured alien, Lokai from the planet Cheron, they're soon further interrupted by Commissioner Bele, an official representing Cheron who announces Lokai as a political traitor and demanding custody. One asylum request later, Kirk's stuck between the two trying to find the right course of action knowing he has orders to follow beyond the situation. The separation between Belle and Lokai is a simple context. And also a strangely charged one looking at it from a […]

trending_flat
[Treknology] The Holodeck

An immersive experience in itself, the Holodeck is one of the many creature comforts that help bring comfort and entertainment within the life of a starship years from home that not only acts in creating a live action gaming environment, but as a useful tool for educational simulations, experiments and the occasional Hirogen nightmare! The holodeck is a complex device. Essentially a simulated environment generator, the holodeck is usually a vast room that used a combination of forcefields, matter replication and visually manipulative holographic systems to create an immersive environment that one or multiple people can use to not only see and hear, but physically interact with. Able to replicate anything from historical settings to an entirely original landscape, the holodeck ios Knightmare in ultra high resolution without a headset or guide, but a physical interaction with a created world […]

trending_flat
A Fistful of Sisko

In the past few years, Star Trek has made several nods to it's past. But while The NExt Generation and Voyager had their continuations, Deep Space Nine continued to 'black sheep' of the family with it's history and name drops being few and far between. Until Academy when we had an entire episode based around the legend of Starfleet's most complex captains. Starting his show as a widower and single parent, Benjamin Sisko started his time in Star Trek as a reluctant hero turned religious icon who's become a prime figure in Bajoran history, the Federation-Dominion war and much more. If you missed his series, first of.... why?! And also, if you want a quick intro - here's our Sisko top five to see what the fuss is all about. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzBkvzPoofQ IN THE PALE MOONLIGHT Season 6, Episode 13 Lets […]

trending_flat
Starfleet Academy to end with with Season 2

Announced first by Variety, it's been announced that Starfleet Academy will end with Season 2. Having just launches in January with the first season finale receiving positive reactions, and it's second season now in post-production following the completion of filming, the announcement comes at an unsurprising time with Paramount undergoing new ownership under Skydance and more business shenanigans with further consolidation in the works with plans to absorb Warner Brothers into the mix. Set in the 32nd century and using Discovery's season 3 'Burn' storyline as a reset point, Starfleet Academy was focused on new original characters who had signed up to be the new stewards of Starfleet's future to rebuild the strength and vision of the Federation. Opening strong, Academy improved throughout it's first season and used it's setting to help strengthen the hopeful vision of the future and […]

Related

trending_flat
Paul Giamatti joins Holly Hunter for Starfleet Academy!

Looking ahead to the next generation of Star Trek shows, Paramount and Secret Hideout have already began announcing new cast members to lead the Starfleet Academy series coming to the streaming platform in the near future. News of the show has already turned heads with notes that the new academy campus will be the largest seen on TV so far, being filmed in Pinewood';s largest stage in Canada, though in terms of what to fully expect from the young adult drama, things are largely being kept under Red Directive secrecy. However we now at least know who will be leading the new class ahead of the shows production...

trending_flat
[Review] Life Itself…. Discovery S5E10

Trapped between two black holes, the doorway to the Progenitor's legacy is wide open. Discovery's on guarding duty following Burnham chasing Moll inside while the Breen are recovering to take the technology for themselves before a rival faction finds them. With everything to fight for and the chase becoming a race against time, Discovery's crew enter their final house and a bit to end their five season journey.

trending_flat
[Review] LaGrange Point: Discovery S5E09

All the pieces of the puzzle have been put together. Now with the end in sight, Burnham and her crew are on the edge of their greatest discovery. Yet there are still obstacles in the way with Moll and the Breen having taken possession of the combined Progenitor Artifact, the USS Discovery dead in the water and a potential all out conflict in the background. No wonder Rayner keeps pacing....

trending_flat
[Review] Labyrinths, Discovery S5E08

Hidden behind trials, tests and general annoyances that would drive even a sane person a little bit mad, the final piece of the puzzle is in sight. Hidden within an ancient travelling archive of the galaxy's most prized knowledge, the only problem is figuring out what it all means. Arriving at the Eternal Library, Captain Burnham opens the pages of an ancient Betazoid manuscript looking for the final answer only to find herself trapped in a psychological game where she doesn't even know the question...

trending_flat
[Review] Erigah: Discovery S5E7

Answering a distress call sent my Mol and L'ak, Discovery apprehends the treasure hunters only to find themselves staring down one of several Breen overlords looking to get their hands on the duo leading to a potential revival of war against the devestating power of the Breen. As Burnham and Vance look for a diplomatic answer to a fight they can't win, Moll looks for a way to escape (of course!) while Stamets rounds up the troops to try and figure out the final clue, including recruiting a bored and frustrated Book...

site2025m

Serving the fan community since 1974, SFC is an international not for profit fan organisation bringing together collective of fans collectively enjoying strange new worlds in science fiction media.

Star Trek and all related, derived or inferred ideas are the intellectual property of Paramount and Paramount Global. No infringement is intended in the use of this material. Starfleet Command Quadrant 2 (SFCQ2) does not generate any income or profit from their endeavours as a fan organisation, no part of which is sanctioned by the Paramount Global group or any sub-division of the legitimate copyright holders.

Core Website layout by Ghostpool. Managed and Maintained by Aim to Misbehave on behalf of Starfleet Command  Quadrant 2

© 2401 Starfleet  Command Quadrant 2 (SFCQ2)

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation