Restless in the monotony of real space exploration, James Kirk is getting impatient for his chance to take the big chair and lead without the overt caution of his Captain during a routine survey mission. Until the monotonous mission suddenly falls into chaos when the planet comes under attack from a devastating weapon that tears the ship apart, leaving Commander Kirk without a captain and without a clue as the USS Farragut is torn to shreds.
Writers: David Reed, Bill Wolkoff
Director: Valarie Weiss
Paul Wesley’s interpretation of a young James Kirk has had it’s moments despite technically not having that much screen time. His first two episodes were alternate realities and even in season three we’ve only had a transporter pattern used to test a holodeck instead of the real deal. So when we do get a look at a rare look at a Kirk before the Captain, it tends to have a purpose in the greater prequel logic and here that purpose is setting the foundation for who Kirk will become when he’s ready to take the chair.
To help with the story, we have the relief team from the Enterprise with some of Kirk’s future command team working with him for the first time. Warping in to save the day, Pike’s Enterprise answered the Farragut distress call. After planting Spock, Uhura, Chapel and Scotty on board, the Enterprise has a bit of a problem of it’s own when the planet killing attackers are revealed in a giant mechanical whale-like ship and capture the Enterprise for salvage while Commander Kirk and his makeshift team are left to watch, unable to help in the broken ship.
In a way it all felt like a prime timeline version of the kelvin timeline movies. Early on Kirk is pushing his captain for a landing party and moments into his argument, the whole planet blows up. From there we get a bit of a bruised ego in the confident Kirk showing that his expectations of what it would be like to be the bold captain in charge versus the reality of being forced to make tough decisions where there’s no room for error isn’t all fun and games. While following similar themes as Into Darkness, it’s done in a more subtle way with the pressure building through a series of unfortunate events and Kirk trying not just to win over the crew, but also win over himself after realising that his original plan would have gotten a lot of people killed.
Playing again on the idea of James Kirk the bookworm instead of the public perception since the 60’s, the story comes off really well, especially with Scotty, as the one person on the away team who hasn’t crossed paths with Kirk until now, raising the pressure with emotive rants pointing out the flaw in every random idea given. And unlike the Kelvin movies, it’s not someone with five minutes experience as there is a heavy emphasis still on Kirk’s experience and professional goals, but even with experience in leadership he’s never had to face this level of intense pressure – and it just keeps building.
It all plays nicely and as Kirk storms off the bridge to clear his head after all his risky heroics plans go wrong, having Uhura nudge the crew into having a little faith in him following their scenes together last season worked nicely to calm the raging Scotsman in the room who’s continuing his lack of grace under pressure story. Laying the foundations for what’s to come, or rather whats already happened with the original series, it was also fairly well done having Spock to accidentally volunteer himself to sort out the not-quite-Captain with his calm Vulcan logic, helping bring balance to help nudge the Captain in the right direction.
Contrasting the struggles on board the Farragut, Pike’s calm and in control of the situation on the Enterprise. Out of the way to let the Farragut’s story take over, Etnterprise is in the bowels of the massive alien ship, tied down with grappling hooks as it’s drained of power ahead of being stripped down for parts. Seeing inside the ship that they’re not the first ship to be stolen and scavenged, Pike and his team have the fun task of breaking free.
Being the B story, there wasn’t that much to their side of things in terms of the action, but it did liven things up a touch. Pike and La’an made for a good pairing with the quipping Captain and his straight faced security trying to fend off scavengers and break their hold while on the bridge Una hands over more control than she’d normally like to follow Pelia’s mad plan; with no power, barely functioning systems and no comms, Pelia builds her own telephone exchange so Ortegas can give commands to Una and M’BEnga manually controlling port and starboard thrusters with parts of an old Atari – courtesy of Pelia’s relentless hoarding.
The reveal of the bad guys felt a bit cliché. They played it out nicely from Pike realising the enemy wouldn’t shoot at him, to finally unmasking another to find the scavengers were humans. After Kirk finds a way to beat the baddies of the week, he’s left with the knowledge that his saving the day was at the cost of over 7,000 humans descended from a pre-warp expedition who had, over the generations, lost their way to becoming brutal pirates taking what they could at any cost to grow and evolve their home ship on the borders. Maybe another nod to the Kelvin Timeline as the idea of simple people becoming monsters as they survived in isolation was a key point of Star Trek Beyond.
In the end, while another side step from the personal side stories that seem to be ticking along off screen, it worked to bring the same themes and learning experiences from the Kelvin timeline in away thats less dramatic and more impactful for Kirk while letting Pike leave him with a lesson in humanity and understanding to help settle his guilt. It’s one of the few episodes that takes the prequel idea and uses it to advance the character backgrounds instead of overwriting them and among the tension and quips, gave us a good story that shows the first challenging command of one of Starfleet’s biggest legends.
Highlights
- Pelia's box of 1980's stuff was wonderful, especially explaining the wonders of what a telephone is to the 23rd century crew.
- "Your bums out the window." Martin Quinn seems to be injecting a lot of good phrases to confuse the no Scots in the room.
- Pike rejecting the oppertunity to volunteer himself for a horrible task will stay in my head for a good long whole.
All Connected...
The bad guy of the week being born of human explorers being thrown into the unknown and suffering for it mirrors the main antagonist of Star Trek Beyond. After the Romulan Wars a MACO turned Starship Captain Edison would get stranded in the late 22nd century along with two other survivors.
Resentful enough with Starfleet and the Federation, he’d modify himself with alien technology and draw in Kelvin Timeline’s Enterprise to become something new, alien and vengeful, eventually breaking free of his isolation and launchign an attack on the prestigeous Yowkrdown Station.
About the author
It’s Not Easy Being Green Blooded: ‘Level Five Transporter Accident’, Strange New Worlds S4E05
Spock's going through a bit of a personal crisis and Scotty's become madly competitive with an old Academy rival. These two separate threads collide in the weirdest way when Spock finds himself as the only person who can control the ship as Scotty's transporter antics turn everyone into puppets... Writers: Henry Alonso Myers & Dana HorganDirector: Jordan Canning Spock's not quite feeling himself and he hasn't quite been himself since the Griffin Incident. And things are getting worse. Leaning heavily towards logic over his exploration of his human side, and in the wake of La'an deciding their relationship had reached it's 'natural conclusion', he's spiraling. Well, as much as a Vulcan would allow themselves to. Desperately trying to balance himself, he's leaning into logic and reaching out to his scorned ex-fiancee for help in re-establishing his Vulcan side.While thats happening, Scotty's on a […]
1701 Shades of Grey: ‘A Case of Chiaroscuro’, Strange New Worlds S4E04
It's been a stressful few months for the Enterprise crew and they want, well, demand, shore leave. Choosing a tech-free planet with natural psychedelics in the atmosphere, the command crew take a shuttle down, take in all the wonders the world provides. And then it all goes a bit wonky... Writers: Skylar Ojeda & Dana Horgan Director: Meera Menon Aside from orbiting a star who's radiation gives an altered perspective of light, Mat'aar XII is a world occupied by Klingon overlords. Having taken control of the population, and implemented strict monitoring and restrictions on movement, the Klingon's rule with fear, torture and by creating division. Like any good occupiers, they've given cushy jobs to some locals including their top Lieutenant, Navatte, a local who proudly wears her silver Klingon armband and interrogates anyone who oppose the Empire. Or so […]
[Departmental] Introducing General Board
The General Board is a relatively new concept and the next evolution of Fleet Support. Mirroring the Captains Table, the General Board is constructed to help overall fleet operations and to contribute more voices and ideas to the clubs operation. Based very loosely on the political 'two house' structure, and named after the real-world General Board within the US Navy in the first half of the 20th century, the starting point was to appoint two sets of voices within the fleet. The Captains represent their unit and their members need within that unit, each representing an area or group that makes up the whole. To contrast and add to the Captains Table, Fleet Support – and now the expanded General Board – allows to give both opinions of fleet leadership and fleet membership equal standing and ensure we hear a […]
Welcoming Our New Fleet Development Officer
To quote Heraclitus, the only constant in life is change. Quadrant 2 has been through many changes before and with the recent appointment of a new Admiralty Board, we're looking ahead with more changes to the fleet structure. With Piers Drinkall joining the board alongside David Shires, there were some discussions about what to do with Piers' Fleet Development role and after some serious thinking, a decision was made. After aiding in Piers' efforts within the Command Training Program, and being a solid right hand on the USS Sovereign, we're pleased to welcome Karl Drinkall to the Fleet Development position. Karl is a sharp mind with a lot to give to the fleet and a clear grasp of our aims and goals in the coming months and years. With his dedication and string mindset, it was an easy decision to […]
[Retro Review] Errand of Mercy
Relations between the Federation and the Klingons are in tatters and the prospect of an all out war casts a shadow over the region. To help prepare for the worst, Kirk and the Enterprise are sent to Organia, a planet populated by inherent pushovers right on the border between Federation and Klingon space. With the prospect of the Klingons getting a foothold that would help their war efforts, Kirk's job is to negotiate a protection order, getting the Organians on their side before the Klingons annexe the planet as a launching pad for conflict. Problem is, the Organians are hardcore pacifists and their native tech is limited. They don't want to be part of any war, and they don't want to change their values to resist. Which becomes a bit of a problem when the Klingons arrive ready to occupy the […]
Dude, Where’s Your Shuttle? Human Best Friend; Strange New Worlds S4E03
It's been a stressful few months for the Enterprise crew and they want, well, demand, shore leave. Choosing a tech-free planet with natural psychedelics in the atmosphere, the command crew take a shuttle down, take in all the wonders the world provides. And then it all goes a bit wonky... Writers: Kathryn LynDirector: Yana Gorskaya Engineers and pilots hate each other. It's the rules. Scotty and Ortegas have been following those rules to the letter, with the bickering pair opening with a dual monologue highlighting how irritating they are to each other between Scotty setting up alerts and alarms to keep the engines in check, and Ortegas duct tapping over the console to get rid of them so she can push the limits freely.While they're constantly irritating each other, the rest of the Alpha shift command team are exhausted. Months […]
Related
It’s Not Easy Being Green Blooded: ‘Level Five Transporter Accident’, Strange New Worlds S4E05
Spock's going through a bit of a personal crisis and Scotty's become madly competitive with an old Academy rival. These two separate threads collide in the weirdest way when Spock finds himself as the only person who can control the ship as Scotty's transporter antics turn everyone into puppets... Writers: Henry Alonso Myers & Dana HorganDirector: Jordan Canning Spock's not quite feeling himself and he hasn't quite been himself since the Griffin Incident. And things are getting worse. Leaning heavily towards logic over his exploration of his human side, and in the wake of La'an deciding their relationship had reached it's 'natural conclusion', he's spiraling. Well, as much as a Vulcan would allow themselves to. Desperately trying to balance himself, he's leaning into logic and reaching out to his scorned ex-fiancee for help in re-establishing his Vulcan side.While thats happening, Scotty's on a […]
1701 Shades of Grey: ‘A Case of Chiaroscuro’, Strange New Worlds S4E04
It's been a stressful few months for the Enterprise crew and they want, well, demand, shore leave. Choosing a tech-free planet with natural psychedelics in the atmosphere, the command crew take a shuttle down, take in all the wonders the world provides. And then it all goes a bit wonky... Writers: Skylar Ojeda & Dana Horgan Director: Meera Menon Aside from orbiting a star who's radiation gives an altered perspective of light, Mat'aar XII is a world occupied by Klingon overlords. Having taken control of the population, and implemented strict monitoring and restrictions on movement, the Klingon's rule with fear, torture and by creating division. Like any good occupiers, they've given cushy jobs to some locals including their top Lieutenant, Navatte, a local who proudly wears her silver Klingon armband and interrogates anyone who oppose the Empire. Or so […]
Dude, Where’s Your Shuttle? Human Best Friend; Strange New Worlds S4E03
It's been a stressful few months for the Enterprise crew and they want, well, demand, shore leave. Choosing a tech-free planet with natural psychedelics in the atmosphere, the command crew take a shuttle down, take in all the wonders the world provides. And then it all goes a bit wonky... Writers: Kathryn LynDirector: Yana Gorskaya Engineers and pilots hate each other. It's the rules. Scotty and Ortegas have been following those rules to the letter, with the bickering pair opening with a dual monologue highlighting how irritating they are to each other between Scotty setting up alerts and alarms to keep the engines in check, and Ortegas duct tapping over the console to get rid of them so she can push the limits freely.While they're constantly irritating each other, the rest of the Alpha shift command team are exhausted. Months […]
Some Scary Ship! The Griffin Incident; Strange New Worlds S4E02
Returning from a conference for future leaders of Starfleet, Spock and La'an (with Kirk hitching a ride) find a long-lost ship adrift. The USS Griffin's disappearance nine years prior had never been explained, becoming a bit of folklore within the fleet. Stum,bling upon it by chance, the trio board the ship hoping to find an answer to the mystery only to get more than they bargained for... Writers: Robbie Thompson Director: Axelle Carolyn I'll preface this now by pointing out I love creepy sci fi settings.. The isolation of being trapped on a derelict ship with no escape and no one to call for help has always been something I've enjoyed from the obvious Event Horizon, even to old classics like The Thing. So I was excited for this one by the trailer alone and can't say I was disappointed! […]
Mars Attacks! Valles Marineris; Strange New Worlds S4E01
Since losing Batel at the end of the last season, life for the crew of the Enterprise hasn't stopped. Mainly because Pike won'd let them. Racing from mission to mission without even a water break in between, the crew are getting a little run down after six months of back to back nonsense. And it's all because of Pike running away from the loss and burying himself in adventure to keep the grief at bay. As Admiral April pops over for a chat, and to offer Pike a promotion he doesnt seem too interested in, a break doesn't seem to be coming any time soon. Writers: Henry Alonso Myers, Alan B. McElroyDirector: Chris Fisher Sent to investigate some new weird space stuff, things go completely mental when the Enterprise gets pulled into it and thrown, Caretaker style, into an unfamiliar […]
Across The Universe And Back To Strange New Worlds!
Time has certainly flown by as Strange New Worlds penultimate season is just days away. Things have been a little guarded since the show was announced to be ending with a shortened 5th season, but it gave the production plenty of warning to wrap things up and bring an end to the original Captain and his crew! With some cast announcements for Season 5 seeing new additions including Thomas Jane as Leonard McCoy, as well as knowing it'll a shorter season to bring the show to a close, the fourth instalment feels a little bittersweet. But from recent hype from Paramount, we might just be in for a fun time. Season 4 Episode Titles Ahead of the series launch, the Star Trek social media team have been hard at work with some teases including short clips of each of the […]
