Since the early years of Star Trek, the Prime Directive has been one of the key elements of Starfleet’s exploration. Sometimes cited as General Order One, the Prime Directive was implemented as an ethical rule to ensure Starfleet and the Federation stayed neutral in the wider galaxy and ensured non interference in any culture or civilisation.
Most commonly used to protect societies that hadn’t quite attained the social or scientific ability to reach the stars like many of the Federation member states, it covered avast array of situations that prevented influencing any culture or civilisation, regardless of intention. It’s a tricky thing to implement and could be broken so easily that it’s interpretation often fell to the captain of any give a mission. Though serious breaches could lead to severe punishment, dismissal or trial.
Of course, that didn’t stop anyone from breaking it when it was necessary. From Sisko and Section 31 influencing the Romulans in the Dominion war, to Worf’s adoptive brother, Nikolai, transporting an entire species covertly to another planet to avoid their natural extinction.
There’s not a season of Trek that goes by without mention, or a breach, or the directive including the latest breach in Discovery where Burnham and Tilly essentially break down an entire religious belief to save people from sacrificing themselves to Denobulan weather towers.
But with near sixty years of breaching the core philosophy of the Federation, it’s far from the first time the laws been broken for the greater good…
The Next Generation, Who Watches the Watchers
Season 3, Episode 4
While monitoring a primitive, early Vulcan-like civilisation, a team of Starfleet observers become compromised by the local population. Being a less advanced, and very far away from warp capable civilisation, Picard’s send to do some damage control. Of course, it all goes wrong and Crushers attempted memory purge fails, leading Picard to break the Prime Directive and meet with their leader.
Despite the number one rule of not interfering with a civilisation that isn’t ready for it, this is one of those rare cases where Picard’s only option as to break the rules. As the one who uncovered the Federation, Liko, remembered the advanced technology he saw the entire population were heading into a superstitious tale-spin. Picard had to intervene to show that they weren’t Gods, and one day the Mindakan’s may also advance as far as the Federations do with time.
Deep Space Nine, Tosk
Season 1, Episode 6
While it ma not jummp out on the top of anyone’s list – especially with Sisko doping much worse over the years – Tosk is one of the best early examples of the iodea of DS9 being a galactic crossroads thanks to the Wormhole. Here a sole renegade shows up and it turns out he’s being hunted. On purpose. Tosk is the prey in basically a big fox hunt in space.
Due to it being a cultural activity, Sisko was unable to intervene unless Tosk sought asylum. Something he refused out of shame. So O’Brien, sympathetic to the fact Tosk only lived to be hunted and killed, let him escape to avoid his death for another day and give him a chance at survival. While Sisko was, this time, not directly responsible for breaking the prime directive he did give O’Brien time to engage his plan while the engineer took his punishment with a mark of pride.
The Original Series, Miri
Season 1, Episode 8
Sometimes there’s a moral conundrum when It comes to whats right in the Prime Directive. Sometimes it’s a no-brainer. Miri was one of the best examples of the latter. Kirk and his team arrive on a planet inhabited only by children. The adults, or grups? All gone. Killed by a plague thats still kicking about. It’s only a matter of time before the children die and the entire civilisation becomes extinct.
The Prime Directive forbids direct action in the event of a planets natural evolution. And a plague, sadly, counts. Faced with breaking Federation law, or using Starfleet medicine to cure them, Kirk chooses not to leave children to die, saving the and their planets future.
Voyager, 30 Days
Season 5, Episode 9
An episode that doesn’t pop in anyone’s head when it comes to the Prime Directive, but one of the few to show one of the crew facing consequences for their actions. The episode revolves around Tom Paris writing a letter to his father, detailing a mission where Voyager ends the Delta Flyer to a civilisation who’s ocean world is losing water on a massive scale. Several solutions are porpoised and only one seems viable for long term help: Deactivating oxygen mines.
While the government refuses, Paris and one of their scientists take matter into their own hands by aiming to destroy the mines:; a plan foiled by Voyager as they detonate Paris’ torpedoes before they can do permanent damage. For violating the Prime Directiver Paris not only spends 30 days in confinement, but is the first leading Star Trek character to be demoted for breaking the sacred rule.
Strange New Worlds ,Strange New Worlds
Season 1, Episode 1
Following Discovery’s battle with Control, Enterprise first officer Una Chin-Riley is tasked with picking up the pieces and goes missing after discovering that fragments from the battle had landed on a pre-warp world. Worse than the technology being placed in the hands of those not ready for it, one nation uses it to create a weapon of mass destruction that could leads to the planets annihilation.
After a covert mission to save his first officer, Pike see’s no other option but to reveal the results of his own planets meddling with such weapons. After interrupting heated and out of control talks between leaders on the cusp of war, Pike reveals the Enterprise as a symbol of hope before having his crew transmit a visual record of Earths past: One with war, lost hope and people turning against each other from an insurrection in a capitol building to the devastation of a third and final world war.
I’s a bit odd to start a show while breaking the big core role of Starfleet, but aside from bringing Pike back with his first adventure and convincing the planet that war wasn’t worth experiencing the same losses of Earth. The best way forward was peace. A nice way to re-introduce Pike as the new lead of his own adventures.
About the author
[Treknology] Beam Me Up!
Step into the transporter and with the touch of a few buttons and sliders you're whisked away to an alien landscape ready to explore. As synonymous to the Star Trek lore as phasers and tricorders, the transporter is one of the most vital tools within Starfleet, letting officers and crew travel instantaneously between environments without the need for time consuming shuttle trips or finding a starship-sized parking space to land in. Developed as a narrative tool, the transporter lets the story move along swiftly without breaks in the action and in a budget friendly manner. All you need to film is someone stepping into the large chamber, paste over some special effects, then pick up in another filming location. Aside from the creative benefits, it also showed the enhanced technological nature of the 23rd century. How it works is fairly […]
That Guy From That Thing: Harris Yulin
Among the many acclaimed guest appearances from all corners of the Star Trek Universe, there are only a small few who gave as deep a performance as Harris Yulin in his sole appearance in the franchise. Taking the spotlight as Aamin Marritza in Deep Space Nine's first season episode Duet, a Cardassian civilian who arrives at Deep Space Nine and raises a massive red flag for Kira when she learns he has a condition that links him to a brutal mining camp that many Bajorans suffered through during the occupation. Yulin is an actor who you may not recognise by name, but you always recognise. Having made his name in the New York theatre scene in the 60's, he quickly established himself as a serious dramatic talent with an incredible command of language, subtly and presence before he'd ever step […]
A Fistful of Justice
Although it's one of the worlds most legendary science fiction shows, Star Trek has always dabbled with format and genre's, all dressed up behind deep space adventures. Whether using the holodeck for a touch of fantasy, or diving into the horrors of war through Deep Space Nine's run, the variety of story telling never seems to fit one mould. But out of all the different tales told in the wonderful world of Starfleet, one that always promises to deliver is the court room drama. This month we're diving into the most captivating of Star Trek's courtroom drama's with a Fistful of Justice! AD ASTRA PER ASPERA Strange New Worlds, Season 2 One of the most modern examples of Strar Trek's court room drama saw Pike's own Number One, Una-Chin Reilly, under court martial for a serious breach of Starfleet regulation […]
Who is The Borg Queen?
Since their first appearance in 1989, the Borg had been an oddly mysterious and chilling antagonist for the Federation. Following their first encounter with the Enterprise-D, an inevitable event accelerated by Q meddling to challenge Picard, the Borg would swiftly make their mark with the first of many attacks on Earth, forcing Starfleet to adapt and change to the new and unexpected threat. A cold, faceless enemy, the Borg are cybernetic beings acting as one collective mind. Spreading through the galaxy trying to find perfection, they absorb anything of value they see into their collective, spreading like a virus and wiping out individuality to become a drone serving their eternal mission. In trying to assimilate the Federation into their collective, the hive created a new leader in Locutus, a human given a unique voice to speak for the Borg and […]
[Q2&A] Fleet Recognition
While SFC's rank system is one of the most obvious form of rewards within Quadrant 2, with members informally given the rank and title for each grade, rank is just one level of recognition within the fleet for out Captains and Fleet Support to highlight a members contributions. While SFC's rank system is one of the most obvious form of rewards within Quadrant 2, with members informally given the rank and title for each grade, rank is just one level of recognition within the fleet for out Captains and Fleet Support to highlight a members contributions. A more common form of recognition are our Commendations and Citations. Having taken various forms over the years, our commendations are the more open of all with four categories – Service, Departmental, Leadership or Special Commendations. Commendations and Special Commendations are the most common […]
[Inside Trek] Behind the Viewscreen: Robert H Justman
It takes an army to bring a TV show to life, especially one creating it's own world to explore in and more often than not the people behind the scenes are often unsung heroes despite being key to the creation of an iconic a legacy as Star Trek. Robert Justman was one of the many responsible to shaping the Star Trek Universe, particularly in it's early days, and was one of the most influential producers in helping form the original series. Staring his career in technical and production roles, Justman learned the ropes in the 1950's as television in the US would go from a rare luxury to a household staple throughout the decade. Building his skills and reputation as assistant director and production manager on a variety of styles, Justman gained a reputation for being highly unorganised and keeping […]
Related
A Fistful of Justice
Although it's one of the worlds most legendary science fiction shows, Star Trek has always dabbled with format and genre's, all dressed up behind deep space adventures. Whether using the holodeck for a touch of fantasy, or diving into the horrors of war through Deep Space Nine's run, the variety of story telling never seems to fit one mould. But out of all the different tales told in the wonderful world of Starfleet, one that always promises to deliver is the court room drama. This month we're diving into the most captivating of Star Trek's courtroom drama's with a Fistful of Justice! AD ASTRA PER ASPERA Strange New Worlds, Season 2 One of the most modern examples of Strar Trek's court room drama saw Pike's own Number One, Una-Chin Reilly, under court martial for a serious breach of Starfleet regulation […]
A Fistful of Sisko
In the past few years, Star Trek has made several nods to it's past. But while The NExt Generation and Voyager had their continuations, Deep Space Nine continued to 'black sheep' of the family with it's history and name drops being few and far between. Until Academy when we had an entire episode based around the legend of Starfleet's most complex captains. Starting his show as a widower and single parent, Benjamin Sisko started his time in Star Trek as a reluctant hero turned religious icon who's become a prime figure in Bajoran history, the Federation-Dominion war and much more. If you missed his series, first of.... why?! And also, if you want a quick intro - here's our Sisko top five to see what the fuss is all about. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzBkvzPoofQ IN THE PALE MOONLIGHT Season 6, Episode 13 Lets […]
A Fistful of Honour Beyond Bloodshed
Feared throughout the galaxy due to being fearless warriors who thrive on battle and bloodshed, the Klingon's are one of Star Trek's most iconic races and yet, with all their history, perhaps the most misunderstood. Starting off in the original series as authoritarian and distrustful antagonist, they were written as a parallel to Russia with the Klingon Empire in a cold war with the Federation following a long conflict. The Klingons would have a bit of reinvention in the movies thanks to higher budgets giving the producers a chance for a more alien look, while their culture and history would get a little more depth on The Next Generation thanks to the inclusion of Worf, the first Klingon member of Starfleet. But Worf's views on the Klingon culture weren't quite spot on. From a noble house, Worf was displaced and […]
A Fistful of Familiar Surroundings
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. President Forward During the Next Generation multiple set pieces were re-used and recycled from the set pieces built for the film franchise. From the obvious re-use of internal corridors, to smaller pieces such as Dr Crushers office being McCoy's, it's hard for a keen eye to ignore how much the productions shared between them. But as The Next Generation became the dominant forcer with ongoing production and full standing sets, eventually the turn tabled and by the final original cast instalment, it was the TNG stages that became the obvious redress solution. The most jarring of the films set re-uses was the office of the president. As Kirk and McCoy were charged with assassination, a political poop show begins and the Federation […]
A Fistful of New Beginnings
The coming of a new year always comes with a feeling of new beginnings. Whether it's hearing the bells at midnight or planning a list of new years resolutions to forget about by February, the changing of numbers and another year ahead can bring us a sense of starting over. To commemorate another year passing, and the beginning of a new Star Trek milestone, we're kicking off with our usual list looking at five times Star Trek itself was able to give itself a fresh start. GROWING THE BEARD Between the first and second seasons of The Next Generation, things changed. A lot. A lot of the Next Generation was just carrying over from the abandoned Phase II and Roddenberry's constant rewrites led to a very inconsistent start for the show. By the second season things has calmed down a […]
A Fistful of Forgotten Technology
Travelling the stars is a lot more fun when you have engineers who can turn rocks into replicators and scientists who come up with some crazy ideas on a whim and bring some brand new tech into creation to solve this weeks problem. But sometimes you have to wonder what happens to the inventions that didn't last the week.... Borg Again Once upon a time, Neelix died. Then Seven came along, casually unstuffed some Borg probes in him and suddenly he's back to life again. Mortal Coil is an episode that focuses on Neelix's belief and psychological after effects of being dead, even if just briefly, only to experience nothing but his revival. It's a common story throughout all genre's of TV. It's just this time there were nanoprobes to speed up the 'coming back to life' part. Seven's nanoprobes […]
