Since the early years of Star Trek, the Prime Directive has been one of the key elements of Starfleet’s exploration. Sometimes cited as General Order One, the Prime Directive was implemented as an ethical rule to ensure Starfleet and the Federation stayed neutral in the wider galaxy and ensured non interference in any culture or civilisation.
Most commonly used to protect societies that hadn’t quite attained the social or scientific ability to reach the stars like many of the Federation member states, it covered avast array of situations that prevented influencing any culture or civilisation, regardless of intention. It’s a tricky thing to implement and could be broken so easily that it’s interpretation often fell to the captain of any give a mission. Though serious breaches could lead to severe punishment, dismissal or trial.
Of course, that didn’t stop anyone from breaking it when it was necessary. From Sisko and Section 31 influencing the Romulans in the Dominion war, to Worf’s adoptive brother, Nikolai, transporting an entire species covertly to another planet to avoid their natural extinction.
There’s not a season of Trek that goes by without mention, or a breach, or the directive including the latest breach in Discovery where Burnham and Tilly essentially break down an entire religious belief to save people from sacrificing themselves to Denobulan weather towers.
But with near sixty years of breaching the core philosophy of the Federation, it’s far from the first time the laws been broken for the greater good…
The Next Generation, Who Watches the Watchers
Season 3, Episode 4
While monitoring a primitive, early Vulcan-like civilisation, a team of Starfleet observers become compromised by the local population. Being a less advanced, and very far away from warp capable civilisation, Picard’s send to do some damage control. Of course, it all goes wrong and Crushers attempted memory purge fails, leading Picard to break the Prime Directive and meet with their leader.
Despite the number one rule of not interfering with a civilisation that isn’t ready for it, this is one of those rare cases where Picard’s only option as to break the rules. As the one who uncovered the Federation, Liko, remembered the advanced technology he saw the entire population were heading into a superstitious tale-spin. Picard had to intervene to show that they weren’t Gods, and one day the Mindakan’s may also advance as far as the Federations do with time.
Deep Space Nine, Tosk
Season 1, Episode 6
While it ma not jummp out on the top of anyone’s list – especially with Sisko doping much worse over the years – Tosk is one of the best early examples of the iodea of DS9 being a galactic crossroads thanks to the Wormhole. Here a sole renegade shows up and it turns out he’s being hunted. On purpose. Tosk is the prey in basically a big fox hunt in space.
Due to it being a cultural activity, Sisko was unable to intervene unless Tosk sought asylum. Something he refused out of shame. So O’Brien, sympathetic to the fact Tosk only lived to be hunted and killed, let him escape to avoid his death for another day and give him a chance at survival. While Sisko was, this time, not directly responsible for breaking the prime directive he did give O’Brien time to engage his plan while the engineer took his punishment with a mark of pride.
The Original Series, Miri
Season 1, Episode 8
Sometimes there’s a moral conundrum when It comes to whats right in the Prime Directive. Sometimes it’s a no-brainer. Miri was one of the best examples of the latter. Kirk and his team arrive on a planet inhabited only by children. The adults, or grups? All gone. Killed by a plague thats still kicking about. It’s only a matter of time before the children die and the entire civilisation becomes extinct.
The Prime Directive forbids direct action in the event of a planets natural evolution. And a plague, sadly, counts. Faced with breaking Federation law, or using Starfleet medicine to cure them, Kirk chooses not to leave children to die, saving the and their planets future.
Voyager, 30 Days
Season 5, Episode 9
An episode that doesn’t pop in anyone’s head when it comes to the Prime Directive, but one of the few to show one of the crew facing consequences for their actions. The episode revolves around Tom Paris writing a letter to his father, detailing a mission where Voyager ends the Delta Flyer to a civilisation who’s ocean world is losing water on a massive scale. Several solutions are porpoised and only one seems viable for long term help: Deactivating oxygen mines.
While the government refuses, Paris and one of their scientists take matter into their own hands by aiming to destroy the mines:; a plan foiled by Voyager as they detonate Paris’ torpedoes before they can do permanent damage. For violating the Prime Directiver Paris not only spends 30 days in confinement, but is the first leading Star Trek character to be demoted for breaking the sacred rule.
Strange New Worlds ,Strange New Worlds
Season 1, Episode 1
Following Discovery’s battle with Control, Enterprise first officer Una Chin-Riley is tasked with picking up the pieces and goes missing after discovering that fragments from the battle had landed on a pre-warp world. Worse than the technology being placed in the hands of those not ready for it, one nation uses it to create a weapon of mass destruction that could leads to the planets annihilation.
After a covert mission to save his first officer, Pike see’s no other option but to reveal the results of his own planets meddling with such weapons. After interrupting heated and out of control talks between leaders on the cusp of war, Pike reveals the Enterprise as a symbol of hope before having his crew transmit a visual record of Earths past: One with war, lost hope and people turning against each other from an insurrection in a capitol building to the devastation of a third and final world war.
I’s a bit odd to start a show while breaking the big core role of Starfleet, but aside from bringing Pike back with his first adventure and convincing the planet that war wasn’t worth experiencing the same losses of Earth. The best way forward was peace. A nice way to re-introduce Pike as the new lead of his own adventures.
About the author
[Retro Review] Dagger Of The Mind
Dropping by a penal colony focused on rehabilitating the criminally insane, the Enterprise beams down some much needed supplies while one of the inmates sneaks on board to beg for asylum. But it's no regular stowaway. Dr Simon Van Gelder used to be part of the staff before he began to lose his mind and he's not just afraid of having dodgy meals and no windows, but reveals to Kirk that the facility runs through torture and abuse. Van Gelder arrived broken. His memories scattered, and any glimpse of those memories would trigger a painful and violent reaction. The colony's lead scientist and essentially warden, Dr Tristan Adams, waves it off claiming Van Gelder's techniques were tested on himself and that the rest of his story was delusional ramblings. Not entirely convinced, and given a heavy nudge by McCoy, Kirk […]
[Treknology] Shields Up! Red Alert!
Different writers, directors and plot points paint Starfleet as multiple and occasionally conflicting things. Both a military and exploratory force, there's many layers to the fleet and how it operates. Handling everything from border defence to mapping unknown territories, even the most mundane mission in peace time can be a risky one. Especially as not every new person you meet will want a cup of tea and a chat, and accidentally dropping into someone's back garden doesn't always go down well.So when the shooting starts, you have to be ready to defend yourself, and in a world of weaponry that could burn an entire planet into ashes, sticking some armour on your hull just isn't going to cut it. One of the most vital systems always ready on stand by, deflector shields help to keep a ship and it's crew […]
Behind the Viewscreen: Gene L Coon
As it's creator, the name Gene Roddenberry is part of the Star Trek legend. But when it came to shaping what the show was, and forming it's foundations, there was another Gene behind the scenes who help build on and refine the shows concepts into the world we know today. Originally brought into the fold in August 1966, Coon was hired to handle day to day production and script revisions during the shows first season, with his first credit appearing on the first seasons eighth episode, Miri. Beyond that day to day production, as well as his creative relationship with Roddenberry, Coon's efforts would help shape the shows identity, helping to form it's unique blend of science fiction, drama and political commentary and in shaping the shows moral compass that would be a keystone of the Star Trek experience. Giving […]
Across The Universe: A Trio of Spocks, 60th Anniversary Goodies and More!
Celebrating 60 years of Star Trek, our September News recap spotlights new goodies for fans to mark the landmark year, new missions for STO fans, and more! Spocktember in Star Trek Online Long running MMO Star Trek Online joined in the anniversary fun by bringing back a legendary character to their September release. On it's original launch STO utilised the vocal talents of Leonard Nimoy as he introduced players to the wider galaxy. In the latest release, archived dialogue from Nimoy has been used to bring Spock back into the new ongoing story.https://youtu.be/Da9UohgplIg?si=pAtm5D1bTSIXxREOAlongside Piotr Michael, who voiced Spock in Star Trek Resurgence, adding new lines as his version of Spock, and introducing Strange New Worlds star Ethan Peck in his own version of the character, all three era's of the iconic Vulcan come together thanks to the Guardian of Forever. […]
[For The Uniform] Generational Upgrade: 2350’s-2370’s
After solidifying a formal military style with stiff dark reds and heavy duty fabrics through the latter half of the 23rd century, the 'Monster Maroons' defined Starfleet as a more serious, more robust organisation. With minor tweaks the look stayed strong for almost 80 years when suddenly Starfleet decided they needed a dramatic change. It's not uncommon. Starfleet goes through uniforms faster, and in more rapid evolutions than any other organisation in history.Maybe it's because of the constant evolution of the Federation? Bringing in new members, new styles, new sensibilities and adapting to their needs. Maybe the MonsterMaroonians joined the Federation and would only absorb their navies into Starfleet if they adapted to their style, and it took eighty years for another species to come in and make fashion related demands. Maybe a new Admiral became Commander in Chief and […]
[Treknology] Clearing The Way: The Deflector
Over the decades the technologies of Star Trek have become so popularised and well known that even someone who's never seen an episode knows what a phaser is, or that warp drive goes really, really fast. Even if someone couldn't tell you what a transporter does, “Beam Me Up” is still a phrase you can say and people will just know what it means.But when you look at ships like the Enterprise, there's one big feature built into every design since that might not be as well known as the saucer, the bridge or the glowing warp nacelles, but is one of the most vital parts of any and all starships flying from planet to planet. When you think of space, you imagine this big empty void of nothingness. But while there is a huge expanse of distance between locations […]
Related
A Fistful of Spooky Encounters
Since it's inception Star Trek hasn't just been a sci fi show, but a show that used it's science fiction setting to tell a variety of stories from a large pool of themes and styles. And since we're officially in 'Spooky Season' on the countdown to Halloween, why not take a look at some of Star Trek's best dives into darkness? EMPOK NOR DEEP SPACE NINE, SEASON 5 Deep Space Nine is falling apart and thanks to the war, O'Brien can't exactly ask the Cardassians for spare parts. But he has a plan. Along with Nog and Garak, O'Brien leads an engineering crew to another abandoned Cardassian station to salvage what they can. Only problem is... there's a reason it was abandoned... Possibly the most straight forward horror story in the series, Empok Nor was host to an experiment gone […]
A Fistful of Undercover Operations
Occasionally when exploring the wonders of deep space, our heroes of Trek have been summoned to - or by sheer accident - become another person to fulfil their mission. Whether it's O'Brien mixing with gangsters or Picard becoming a mercenary, Star Trek's filled with episodes where our favourite explorers have to become someone else to save the day.... FACE OF THE ENEMY The Next Generation Season 6 Waking up on the Warbird Khazara, Deanna Troi finds herself in a bit of a pickle. Kidnapped and surgically altered to take the place of a Tal Shiar Commander she finds herself led by her handler, N'Vek, to lead a secret mission after the Commander had been killed. Out of her comfort zone, Troi has to convince the crew she's the real deal despite the ships skipper knowing something's not quite right.... In […]
A Fistful of Down To Earth Adventures
Warping through the stars always searching for the next adventure, it's rare that Star Trek ever comes home to Earth. Through all the series, and highlighted in Enterprise, the third rock from our sun is kinda important in the grand scheme of things but our eyes are always far beyond the stars. So for no particular reason at all - certainly not any recent new series launching - we're taking a look at Trek's more Earthbound moments.... Homefront/Paradise Lost Deep Space Nine Season 4 The Founders said they were everywhere. Now we know they're on Earth. Recordings revealed a founder during the bombing of a Federation meeting on the home-world and Sisko is recalled. His knowledge and experience with the Dominion is vital to securing Earth against the inevitable war. But while the Dominion may be the enemy, they aren't […]
A Fistful of ‘Spirk’
We've been spoiled with Spock in the past few years with Discovery introducing a younger iteration of the character long before he became the refined man of logic that made him famous, and continued that story through Strange New Worlds and his time under Captain Pike's command. As Strange New Worlds continues, giving more history to the original series line up and the early meetings of Spock and Kirk as it makes way for the beginning of the Kirk era, we thought we'd look back at some moments that made the partnership one of the most popular combinations in science fiction. JOURNEY TO BABEL TOS Season 2 Spock's got a bit of an issue with sharing. Secret brother who was shunned. Secret sister who's fate was classified. And despite trusting the Enterprise crew with his life, it was clearly only […]
A Fistful of O’Brien
Entering the Star Trek world as an unnamed extra with a few bits of dialogue, O'Brien soon became a fixture on the Enterprise D as it's transporter chief before moving to Deep Space Nine to head up engineering and operations on what was thought to be a backwater outpost before it became one of the most strategically important stations in the quadrant!As the only enlisted or non commissioned officer to feature in the main cast of any Star Trek show to date, O'Brien stands as the only working class hero in the Star Trek universe with a vast and varied career taking from the front lines of the Cardassian war as a soldier, to the front lines of the Dominion War as an engineer, retrofitting DS9, keeping the Defiant from blowing itself apart, and even sniping Dominion troops. All in […]
A Fistful of Justice
Although it's one of the worlds most legendary science fiction shows, Star Trek has always dabbled with format and genre's, all dressed up behind deep space adventures. Whether using the holodeck for a touch of fantasy, or diving into the horrors of war through Deep Space Nine's run, the variety of story telling never seems to fit one mould. But out of all the different tales told in the wonderful world of Starfleet, one that always promises to deliver is the court room drama. This month we're diving into the most captivating of Star Trek's courtroom drama's with a Fistful of Justice! AD ASTRA PER ASPERA Strange New Worlds, Season 2 One of the most modern examples of Strar Trek's court room drama saw Pike's own Number One, Una-Chin Reilly, under court martial for a serious breach of Starfleet regulation […]
