Over the years the Star Trek Universe has shown one part of it’s original cast to be thee glue that holds it all together. From tempering Kirks emotions in the original series, to becoming a key asset in Starfleet’s mission for peace decades later, Spock has been intertwined into several key points in galactic history.
His appearance in The Next Generation led to a cultural shift over time that saw Romans and Vulcan’s living as one nation. His disappearance during the Romulan Supernova led to the creation of the Kelvin Timeline. Even his strained relationships with his half brother and foster sister would have huge ramifications that would have an undeniable butterfly effect throughout time.
But in essence, Spock’s existence throughout most of his achievements shouldn’t have happened. During Kirk’s final showdown with Khan, Spock sacrificed himself to save the ship and his crew. It was only down to his casket being shot into space and accidentally landing on the Genesis planet that saw his remains remade to give a whole new second life to the shell left behind. If that pod never landed, or if Kirk had simply googled Vulcan death rituals and realised it was generally a bad idea, how would the universe be effected by the loss of that one constant?
Following Spocks death, Kirk was put back behind the desk and the Enterprise was being set aside for a new era of Excelsior Class replacements. Having properly done some research, Kirk would return to Earth with Spock’s remains and handed them kindly over to Sarek who – at some point, surely – would have figured out the bits he really needed were in McCoys head. Hijinks would surely ensue.
Meanwhile, the Grissom is still having a poke around this newly formed planet. It’s still a galactic controversy and the Grissom is still checking it all with nothing to back it up, making it a prime target for Kruge to sneak past the diplomatic shouting going on back on Earth.
As Kirk grumbles away to himself, trying to fight through a batch of paperwork as he settles back into the mundane life of an Admiral in a fleet accelerating past his prime, leaving Scotty to grumble about the Excelsior class ships and lecture young engineers on how to do things properly, Kruge finds there’s nothing stopping him taking the Grissom, claiming Genesis as his own and seeing how destructive it truly is, getting everything he needs to begin to reverse engineer the technology for The Empire.
Kruge’s plans wouldn’t be an overnight success, of course. Thats a lot of work to recreate. But while the Federation and the Empire waste time with investigations and accusations, Kurge would be able to use the distraction to pull off a successful weapons test and gain support to unite more than a few houses to get behind his cause to make the Empire great again!
It wouldn’t be a hard campaign. Especially as the opportunity to strike would present itself quickly as by the time Kruge had gained support, the Federation would already have been dealing with a major catastrophe; the devastation of Earth by an unknown alien probe who ripped the planet apart and left nothing but chaos, destruction and death behind. Widespread devastation on one of the capitol worlds of the Federation, and home to Starfleet, would have left the planet in ruins and allies scrambling to provide aid and refuge.
Kirk, still alive because of course he is, would step up to take control after the destruction of Federation headquarters, using what was left of the fleet to try and reassemble some form of defences. Especially as, while still dealing from the fallout, the Klingons prepare to finish what the probe started.
In an era where Klingon factions are looking for war, including high profile leader General Chang, there’s no need for a cooperative conspiracy that would have came in 2393. By that point the war would have engaged itself; Praxis a small blip compared to the power the Empire received from Kruge’s new weapon and incomparable to the remnants of Earth.
The war Spock and Chancellor Gorkon had managed to avert through peace would be inevitable. Kirk’s prejudice following the capture of the Grissom, and his son’s demise through treatment Kirk could only have nightmares about, would be easy to manipulate without his conscience to guide him forward of give logical words of wisdom.
Peace may come, eventually. But the mid 23rd century had shown the Klingons they could win the war against the Federation, and with revived bloodlust the unifying influence of L’Rell would fall too the wayside, putting Starfleet in full defensive mode against a powerful and unstoppable enemy.
The peaceful era of the Next Generation may still arrive, a hopeful future somewhere on the horizon. But with a crippled Earth and an Empire fighting for dominance, that peace would be a long way off and with a dramatic shift in the political landscape.
Of course, theres always the chance Kruge was never going to get the secret of Genesis and die with the planet as a complete failure. Someone else could figure out the Whale Dilema. And if that kept things calm, it could have been Sarek leading the way with Gorkon following the Praxis incident. But with no Spock, the chance of the universe collapsing into war in just a few short years becomes a possible reality and shows that when it comes to ‘What If?’ in the Star Trek Universe, Spock’s influence being removed would be the one thread that could pull the tapestry apart…
About the author
Resistance Is Optional: Sunday 8th February
We've trialled, we've tested and we're ready for nonsense! This weekend we're inviting the fleet to come together and just enjoy talking Trek, general life, throw questions at Admin and generally misbehave in our Discord server while we run a live first run on the server. For those who've never used Discord before, we're migrating what we can from our social platforms to the Discord server in the coming weeks and months due to it's versatility as a desktop app, web-based client or mobile app; having multiple methods of communication from voice chats, to hosted events, to simple forum and live forum style discussions and of course – aside from them occasionally promoting their Nitro features – it’s ad and payment free with privacy controls to suit you. Also it lets us run video and voice chat - both of […]
“There is no greater enemy than one’s own fears”; ‘Vox In Exelso’, Starfleet Academy S1E4
When an existential crisis threatens to wipe out a beloved but infamous Star Trek species, a cadet is forced to confront his past and strained relationship with his family. As he pursues an unexpected method of coping, Nahla races against time to save this species from extinction.... Writers: Gaia Violo & Eric Anthony Glover Director: Doug Aarniokoski Ever since Discovery took the jump to the future, there were questions that were left unanswered. A few hundred yeas of changing cultures and political landscapes combined with the galaxy-devastating effect of the Burn gave us a familiar surrounding that had undergone massive change. We found out what happened to the Federation. We found out the Orions took advantage of the power vacuum. We even got to meet an isolationist Earth and see the reunification of Vulcan and Romulus. But for a […]
Revenge Of The Nerds; ‘Vitus Reflux’, Starfleet Academy S1E3
Proving yourself at Starfleet Academy always seemed to come down to competitive rivalry. Whether it was Sisko failing to win over Solok, Finnegan's constant pranks on Kirk, or Georgiou drinking everyone under the table, even the most professional stand up Captains have spent their youth in a knife fight with a Nausican. Vitrus Reflux get it all out the way as cadets Lythe and Raymi get locked into a battle of the ego's while the War College next door pops up to assert their dominance! Writers: Alex Taub & Kiley RossetterDirector: Doug Aarniokoski As the more militaristic war college use their current standing as the primary source of Starfleet for the past hundred-plys years to prove the revival of the Academy is a failed experiment, tensions begin to bubble over through mixed physical training leading to conflicts, a war of words and […]
[Q2&A] Positively Positive.
Last week Starfleet Academy debuted and something odd happened. If you're a regular to any Trek news or discussion site, you noticed a spike. Even our usually sleepy Facebook profile went from a handful of likes to over 2,000, am good chunk of which got deleted. It wasn't a normal spike, certainly not normal for a debut show, not normal to be everywhere and – to be frank – not normal in terms of comments. It was a mix of disturbing and sad. Disturbing for the high amount of bigoted and sexist memes and commentary that seemed to mock murdered US citizens. For a subculture of fandom that grew up praising – to the point of gloating – that Star Trek was about intellectualism and inclusion, it certainly showed that as a fandom, and a united international culture, we've taken more […]
[Retro Review] Where No Man Has Gone Before….
During a search and rescue mission that takes the Enterprise through the Galactic Barrier, ships captain James 'R' Kirk has another problem. During the trip through the barrier, Kirks crewmate and long time friend Gary Mitchell takes a blast of weird energy that slowly transforms him into everyone's best friend, to a telekinetic megalomaniac proving that old parable about absolute power.... By this point, everyone knows the story of Star Trek's two pilots. The Cage was filmed, rejected and the show got a rare second chance. That second chance as Where No Man Has Gone Before. Same ship, different Captain and crew aside from a green blooded alien... This year marks the 60th anniversary of Star Trek, so it seems only fitting we should start, where the show began on screen with the pilot that saw the idea become a […]
Everything Whale Be Alright; ‘Beta Test’, Starfleet Academy S1E2 Review
Rebuilding after being torn down by 'The Burn', Starfleet and the Federation are getting back on mission, rekindling old alliances, developing new technologies and now ready to re-open Starfleet Academy to raise the next generation of explorers... Writers: Noga Landau & Jane Maggs Director: Alex Kurtzman Whether it's seeing hios potential, or just sheer guilt, Captain Ake is bending over backwards to integrate Caleb into the Academy. Trouble is, he's not putting in the same effort. Fighting against his own inflated ego and distracted with his quest to find his mother coming to a dead end. Spiralling following an argument with instructor Jet Reno, Caleb tries to run, but instead he runs into Tarima; a visiting Betazoid who can see right through his bravado. Following the Burn, Betazed isolated itself from the Federation and now their president has an […]
Related
What If…. the Romulans Learned The Truth?
Armed to the teeth with the ability to replenish ships, troops and supplies at rapid speed, the Dominion were a force to be reckoned with who were systematically crushing their opposition. The Jem'Hadar were taking their fair share of losses, but any soldier lost could be replaced by another batch of clones and with a huge amount of planets in servitude to the Dominion combined with a sharp focus of genetically engineered talents, there were always spare resources to replenish and push back. It was a dire situation for the Federation. Waves of fleets would be lost in battle, boots on the ground were struggling to hold the line and even with the Klingons vast resources and more battle-ready way of life, it just wasn't enough to push back hard enough against the invading Dominion. Not until another large nation […]
Relay Recap: July 2024
All Features Universe Categories Fleet Alert Comms GORN GIRL recap; july 2025 Picking up on the Season 2 cliff-hanger, Strange New Worlds returned to our screens this month to find Captain Pike and his crew on the edge of war with the Gorn as Season 3 was finally released!Exploring new worlds and new problems, the Enterprise crew are back in action on Paramount Plus and we're keeping ourselves up to date with weekly episode discussion threads on our FB Continuing Mission Group & Weekly episode reviews from Admin ! Explore... Episode Reviews Spoilers Group ACROSS THE UNIVERSE As we look back on Pike's adventures on the Enterprise in the prequel series, Paramount also gave us a look at whats to come next as Entertainment Weekly and SDCC's Star Trek Universe panel gave us a sneak peek at the reopening of […]
What If…. there was no Next Generation?
On the announcement of a new Star Trek show there was a lot of pushback. Most were excited at the idea of a new era, but some felt a new rehash of the concept was a mistake. It'll never work. The dynamics weren't right. They'd missed the point of what Star Trek was. It wasn't in the spirit of what came before. The casting was wrong, none of the new cast seemed likable It was doomed before it even began. And no, this wasn't Discovery. Nor the series of films introducing an alternate reality that played on the idea of Kirk and Spock fulfilling their destiny despite their radically changed origins. This was 1987 before the Star Trek Universe even existed. As of now (June 2025), Star Trek as an overall franchise consists of 818 episodes of live action over […]
[What If] The Defiant Does The Delta Quadrant
Time is broken, according to Q. So why not break it some more? Over the years we've seen alternate glimpses of our Starfleet heroes. From Terran Counterparts who's lives moved in rapidly different directions, to small changes as Worf zapped through parallel worlds to alternate futures threatening to destroy all of humanity. Looking back at what could have been, we're blatantly copying Marvel's ongoing What If series to look at hor Star Trek could have changed with a few small differences and to start, we're putting our focus on the Maquis...
