Fondly remembered as the lightest, more comedic entries in Star Trek’s film offerings, The Voyage Home is the story of an alien probe coming to Earth to talk to it’s whale pen pal, a little bit miffed that they’ve not had a letter in a while. In the 21st century, those pen pals – Humpback Whales – had been hunted to extinction. Meanwhile, Kirk and his disgraced crew were on the way home to stand trial and through some time warp shenanigans, take a stolen Bird of Prey back to the 20th century, kidnap some whales, and take them to the 23rd century to save the day.
The charges against Kirk were a fairly big deal. Previously Kirk had stolen a soon to be retired Enterprise, went against orders and along with support from his long standing command crew barged their way into restricted space in the hopes of recovering Spocks body. At the time they were unaware Spocks body had been reborn by Genesis, or that some rogue Klingons were on their way to steal the technology which made things more complicated.
In the end they recovered Spocks body, reconnected with his ‘katra’, but in the mix destroyed the stolen Enterprise, killed a Klingon commander and commandeered his ship. So it wasn’t just Starfleet who wanted his head, it was the Klingons as well. The only saving grace for Kirk was that on his way back to Earth, he accidentally got to save the planet which had his massive punishment become a mild slap on the wrist as he was ‘demoted’ from desk job down to Starship Captain and gifted a brand new Enterprise to replace the one he blew up.
So what if that probe never made it’s way to Earth, if the whales were never extinct and kept chatting over the centuries, and the (former) Enterprise crew didn’t have their chance to be heroes on the way home….
In a world in which Admiral Kirk leads his crew to Earth without a distraction, the story of the legendary crew would likely come to an abrupt end. By this point in time Kirks a man with a reputation, but his glory days far behind him. Settled into the Admiralty, with only two very brief stints in command of a starship since he gave up the chair, the situation isn’t one he can run from this time.
Aside from disobeying orders, stealing and then causing the destruction of the Enterprise, and being somewhat responsible for sabotaging the USS Excelsior, Kirk’s actions may have saved Spock and given him a second chance at life, but it also became a political nightmare for the Federation. What had become known as the Genesis planet wasn’t the dream Carol Marcus thought it would be. The unstable result of the Genesis device being used had created a whole new planet, but was also a deadly weapon. Klingons in the mix, even if they weren’t leading heroes of the empire, had given an excuse for tensions to rise yet again.
Without a whale related emergency. Kirk would arrive at Earth to hear the music. And that music would likely be his curtain call. Punishment such as demotion or a custodial sentence may have been enough. But to appease the Klingons and highlightt he severity of the situation, Kirk, with his best days behind him, would surely be made an example of. Dishonourable discharge. The Admiral becomes the civilian and whatever else may come, the Klingons would stand down while Starfleet made a statement to their own to stay in line.
Kirk wasn’t the only party involved. He may be responsible for his crew, but they also joined his quest willingly. McCoy had to be dragged back to Starfleet. With his reluctance to be there combined with losing the person who’d convinced him to stay, he’d have an easy out to settle down into a quaint country practice. Scotty would likely also be on the way out, not only for his direct part in sabotaging the Excelsior, but in being a relic already refusing to accept the next steps. At best, a teaching role may be in his future but much like Kirk, Captian Scott would likely be at the end of his career.
Uhura and Chekov might accept demotion, but likely play along to settle into lesser roles while Sulu’s career would take the biggest hit with his career aspirations derailing his path to the captains chair. Though with the crew scattered and disbanded, moving into new lives for better or worse, it’s Spock’s fate that carries the biggest question.
In a world where the dead has literally risen from the grave, Spock’s future isn’t as certain as it was in The Voyage Home. At the end of the film, he stood proudly back in uniform as he readjusted to his old self. But without Kirk and McCoy bringing balance, and no Enterprise to define his later Starfleet career, he’d be a man of two worlds who may not walk the same path as he had before.
In the timeline we all know, Kirk get bumped down to Captain and given the Enterprise-A. The A’s final mission was one that would have the most effect if those events never take place. In the year 2293, the Enterprise A and it’s crew were getting ready for riding into the sunset when the Klingon moon Praxis – a valued resource of the empire – exploded. The explosion caused a ripple effect that changed the future of the Federation and the quadrant.
As the son of Ambassador Sarek, and having the luck of a peace-loving Klingon Chancellor on his side, Spock was able to negotiate for peace using Kirk and the legend of the Enterprise as the olive branch. But without the Whales, there is no Captain Kirk. There is no Enterprise. And while branches can be plucked from any tree, even if they’d sent someone else in their place, the combination of the Enterprise crew and Excelsior for support may not have foiled the conspiracy to re-engage in open warfare.
If Kirk and Spock as a combination aren’t there to stop the conspiracy, there’s no Khitomer Accords to bring peace between the Federation and the Klingon Empire. And maybe, just maybe, that brings us a little closer to the world Jean Luc Picard was living in during Yesterdays Enterprise with Admiral Cartwright getting the war he so desperately wanted.
There’s other outcomes and problems to consider, of course. But if there’s no whales to save, no probe to reason with and no legacy made for Kirk or the Enterprise, the future of the Federation – and of Star Trek itself – would be very different.
About the author
What If…. the Whales Were Never Extinct?
Fondly remembered as the lightest, more comedic entries in Star Trek's film offerings, The Voyage Home is the story of an alien probe coming to Earth to talk to it's whale pen pal, a little bit miffed that they've not had a letter in a while. In the 21st century, those pen pals – Humpback Whales – had been hunted to extinction. Meanwhile, Kirk and his disgraced crew were on the way home to stand trial and through some time warp shenanigans, take a stolen Bird of Prey back to the 20th century, kidnap some whales, and take them to the 23rd century to save the day. The charges against Kirk were a fairly big deal. Previously Kirk had stolen a soon to be retired Enterprise, went against orders and along with support from his long standing command crew barged […]
[Retro Review] The Doomsday Machine
Responding to a distress call from the USS Constellation, the Enterprise race to the rescue but they arrive too late to save the day. Coming under fire from an alien entity, the Constellation has been heavily damaged and with only one survivor within it's charred shell; Commodore Matt Decker... Still in shock from the attack, Decker isn't able to say if it was an alien ship, or a creature that tore his ship apart. It doesn't take long to track the aliens flight path. It's not from around these parts, entering the Galaxy and on course towards populated areas that would undoubtedly be next in it's devastating path. Beaming on board with an away team, Kirk aims to try and get whats left of the ship back up and running while getting Decker to safety. But during the transit, the […]
Under Pressure: ‘Orders Of Magnitude’, Strange New Worlds S4E08
Boarding as a hero and legend, Admiral Joe Reeger arrives, take command and leaves Pike stranded as he leads the remaining Enterprise crew on an urgent mission. With a visiting (again!) James Kirk picked out as first officer, Reegers mission and motivations come into question and puts Kirk's leadership to task... Writers: Alan B McElroy Director: Sharon Lewis One thing about season four that's been a highlight through some uneven episodes is how it's guiding it's characters form our first contact with them in this series, and how we originally met them sixty years earlier. While it's been more obvious with Spock's pivot towards being closer to his logical side, we've had Chapel make the choice to become a permanent part of the Enterprise and Scotty's move towards being the 'miracle worker'. Even Pike seems to be on the […]
Days of Our Unreal Lives: ‘Like Chronitons Through The Hourglass’, Strange New Worlds S4E07
Waking up in sickbay with a comical bandage on his head following a shuttle accident, Pike quickly notices things are a bit off. The lights are too bright. The medical staff are behaving oddly with dramatic pauses aplenty. And he's fairly certain space madness isn't a genuine diagnosis. As the hour continues with devious secret siblings, dramatic feats of medicine and family drama aplenty, Pike is drawn further into the strangest of all worlds; the soap opera. Writers: Dana Horgan and Bill WolkoffDirector: Anna Dozoka Soap opera's are mental. And for a theme it's even more mental than it seems. But considering soap opera's are basically just overly dramatic premises with long lost relatives you'd never before heard of, absolutely insane scenario's that make Maggie Simpson shooting Mr Burns seem normal and plot twists so insane you genuinely have to […]
Star Trek Day 2026: Celebrating 60 Years of the Final Frontier!
Sixty years ago the world was introduced to a sci fi series that planted a seed of adventure, imagination and inspiration that would blossom into a juggernaut of media. After launching with the Man Trap on September 8th in the United States, the series would later grow into a pop culture icon spawning 9 Live Action Series, 3 Animated Series, 13 Feature Films & more including Streaming Events, Shorts and a huge amount of offshoot media across games, comics and books. With generations of fans discovering new era's and new adventures for decades, today we celebrate not only that first flight of the USS Enterprise and it's original crew, but an entire franchise that continued to grow, evolve, building a world of adventure, inspiration and hope for a better future! As we celebrate Star Trek at 60, we'd love to hear how […]
Away Team, Assemble! The USS Tesla Set To Beam Down to Epic Comic Con!
Returning to Glasgow this September, the Tesla Crew are once again in action at Fan Frontiers Epic Comic Con in the SEC Hosted by Fan Frontiers, Epic Comic Con has been one of the core places to meet the crew of the Tesla since it’s origins as Acme Comic Con and has become a firm part of the diverse and welcoming fan centric communities hosting everything from Rebel Legions to Ghostbusters! Taking their regular spot once again the Tesla crew will have Star Trek props and collectables on display as the team get ready to share the wonders of the final frontier! With possibly the biggest and most intriguing line ups to date, Epic will be hosting some surprises including Lord of the Rings' hobbit Duo Billy Boyd & Dominic Monaghan, What We Do in the Shadows Star Kayvan Novak, […]
Related
What If…. the Romulans Learned The Truth?
Armed to the teeth with the ability to replenish ships, troops and supplies at rapid speed, the Dominion were a force to be reckoned with who were systematically crushing their opposition. The Jem'Hadar were taking their fair share of losses, but any soldier lost could be replaced by another batch of clones and with a huge amount of planets in servitude to the Dominion combined with a sharp focus of genetically engineered talents, there were always spare resources to replenish and push back. It was a dire situation for the Federation. Waves of fleets would be lost in battle, boots on the ground were struggling to hold the line and even with the Klingons vast resources and more battle-ready way of life, it just wasn't enough to push back hard enough against the invading Dominion. Not until another large nation […]
Relay Recap: July 2024
All Features Universe Categories Fleet Alert Comms GORN GIRL recap; july 2025 Picking up on the Season 2 cliff-hanger, Strange New Worlds returned to our screens this month to find Captain Pike and his crew on the edge of war with the Gorn as Season 3 was finally released!Exploring new worlds and new problems, the Enterprise crew are back in action on Paramount Plus and we're keeping ourselves up to date with weekly episode discussion threads on our FB Continuing Mission Group & Weekly episode reviews from Admin ! Explore... Episode Reviews Spoilers Group ACROSS THE UNIVERSE As we look back on Pike's adventures on the Enterprise in the prequel series, Paramount also gave us a look at whats to come next as Entertainment Weekly and SDCC's Star Trek Universe panel gave us a sneak peek at the reopening of […]
What If…. there was no Next Generation?
On the announcement of a new Star Trek show there was a lot of pushback. Most were excited at the idea of a new era, but some felt a new rehash of the concept was a mistake. It'll never work. The dynamics weren't right. They'd missed the point of what Star Trek was. It wasn't in the spirit of what came before. The casting was wrong, none of the new cast seemed likable It was doomed before it even began. And no, this wasn't Discovery. Nor the series of films introducing an alternate reality that played on the idea of Kirk and Spock fulfilling their destiny despite their radically changed origins. This was 1987 before the Star Trek Universe even existed. As of now (June 2025), Star Trek as an overall franchise consists of 818 episodes of live action over […]
What If… Spock Never Returned?
Over the years the Star Trek Universe has shown one part of it's original cast to be thee glue that holds it all together. From tempering Kirks emotions in the original series, to becoming a key asset in Starfleet's mission for peace decades later, Spock has been intertwined into several key points in galactic history. His appearance in The Next Generation led to a cultural shift over time that saw Romans and Vulcan's living as one nation. His disappearance during the Romulan Supernova led to the creation of the Kelvin Timeline. Even his strained relationships with his half brother and foster sister would have huge ramifications that would have an undeniable butterfly effect throughout time. But in essence, Spock's existence throughout most of his achievements shouldn't have happened. During Kirk's final showdown with Khan, Spock sacrificed himself to save the […]
[What If] The Defiant Does The Delta Quadrant
Time is broken, according to Q. So why not break it some more? Over the years we've seen alternate glimpses of our Starfleet heroes. From Terran Counterparts who's lives moved in rapidly different directions, to small changes as Worf zapped through parallel worlds to alternate futures threatening to destroy all of humanity. Looking back at what could have been, we're blatantly copying Marvel's ongoing What If series to look at hor Star Trek could have changed with a few small differences and to start, we're putting our focus on the Maquis...
